📄 Extracted Text (1,825 words)
BOOTHBAY
B FUND MANAGEMENT, LLC
April 26, 2016
Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies, LP (the "Fund") 2016 Q1 net return was an estimated (1.37%)2 versus
+0.77% for the S&P 500, (2.59%) for the HFRX Global Hedge Fund Index, and (0.58%) for the HFRX
Absolute Return Index.
Net Returns (%)
HFRX Index Absolute Return HFRX Index Global Hedge
Boothbay S&P 500
Index Fund
Q12016 -1.37% 0.77% -0.58% -1.87%
March -1.20% 6.60% -0.29% 1.24%
February 0.36% -0.41% -0.35% -0.32%
January -0.53% -5.07% 0.05% -2.76%
Since opening the Fund to external investors on July 1, 2014, Boothbay has returned 10.26%2, versus 5.08%
for the S&P 500 during the same period.
Performance and Conunentary
QI of 2016 was our Fund's most challenging quarter yet. As we had warned in the Q4 letter, our streak
of 14 consecutive positive months was certain to end at some point. The streak ended in January, which
portended an even more difficult March.
In the general markets, it was a very unusual quarter. The S&P 500 Index was relatively flat through
March, despite having experienced a steep sell-off and recovery. Despite this modestly positive market
performance, hedge fund returns were very poor. An industry note from Morgan Stanley said that Q1
2016 was the worst quarter for stock picking alpha in at least 7 years. Returns were especially bad for
relative value multi-manager multi-strategy firms, the category Boothbay falls in. Overall, the quarter
was our worst, and brought about some questions and challenges to the wider multi-strategy category,
while at the same time offering affirmation for what we do differently at Boothbay.
What happened?
In our view, several items collided to force one of the hedge fund industry's largest-ever deleveraging
events. The alternative investment world has changed materially. Leverage is more appropriate for
relative value multi-manager multi-strategy firms, as they are, among other things, market-neutral and
diversified. As a result, there is an astounding amount of money, as measured by gross market value, in
these strategies.
Liquidations and turnover from at least one large platform (leaving some arguing the giant platforms
have become too large), combined with an abnormally volatile January, created market-wide losses,
causing many firms to start deleveraging; first at the sub advisor level as automatic risk stop-outs were
triggered, and then at the fund levels, giving rise to a major cascading effect. When market-neutral
funds deleverage, they are selling longs that they believe they should own and covering or buying shorts
that they think will go down. This risk-based non-economic buying and selling causes strange market
dynamics. Value based investors who buy on the cheap with a margin of safety set an effective floor on
stocks being sold, but the opposite (a short seller that needs to be short a stock at a given price) doesn't
exist. This resulted in a vicious short covering rally. Not surprisingly, Boothbay's returns on days the
1
EFTA01088814
BOOTHBAY
B FUND MANAGEMENT, LLC
market was down in the quarter were very positive, with more than 250% of our losses coming on days
the market was up. Knowing that a deleveraging has happened, even when it is happening, and
knowing what to do about it are two different things. Do we not want to be in the "smart longs and
smart shorts"? Of course we do.
How can we avoid these deleveraging losses?
While not totally immune, we were much less affected than our peers, with reported numbers down
between 4% and 17% for the quarter, including some losses that may lead to fund closures. The fact we
lost 1.37% during what we believe is a worst-case market, while unpleasant, appears in context to be a
relative accomplishment.
We are not happy to ever lose money, but losing less than our peers is a further proof of concept for how
we have designed our product to be a bit different from other multi-strategy funds. Our losses were
cushioned by at least three factors: I) Our First-Loss strategy, 2) our ability to allocate capital to more
niche, uncorrelated strategies, and 3) our managers' ability to position a larger percentage of our
portfolio in less-crowded names and themes, which were less subject to the deleveraging.
Our three biggest manager losers cost us more than 100% of our Fund losses for the quarter, specifically
in the energy and technology sectors. These managers have strong and proven performance records,
both with us and prior to joining Boothbay. We still believe they can make us materially more in the
future, so their risk was reduced to a smaller size in some cases, but not terminated.
Our robust sourcing effort continues to improve, and we are excited about the pipeline of managers,
including an increase in the size of the First-Loss platform.
While no fund can have absolute protection from difficult periods, we strive to reduce correlation and
improve downside protection during times of stress. Since inception, we have communicated that we
intend to run Boothbay in a way that +I- 2.5% months should generally happen once every 20 months.
We are not macro experts, but we expect equity market volatility to remain high. In any event, there are
certainly material mispricings that our traders should be able to take advantage of in the coming months.
I hope we protect capital this well in other similar periods. If we do, we will be around to make money
in the better market environments when they come.
Team
On the business side, we have made a significant hire. Peter Bremberg joined Boothbay on April 18 as
our Chief Operating Officer. Peter was our primary representative at BNP Paribas, one of our major
counterparties, and has worked closely with us for the past three years. We have been impressed with
his skills and experience as well as his temperament. I think he will be an incredibly valuable asset to
our organization as we build for the future. Peter will allow us to continue to bring operational best
practices to Boothbay. He has unique knowledge of the inner workings of prime brokers, especially as
they relate to margin and financing, counterparty risk, trading, and other material business items.
Moreover, his presence and ability to handle high-level, day-to-day issues will free me up to engage in
more strategic endeavors.
I look forward to integrating Peter into our team on a more formal basis and I expect his presence here
will ultimately show up in the Fund's bottom line. We are cautious about growth and fit, and are
confident we have the right person to help us not only continue on the path we have started, but to take
us to new heights. I know Peter looks forward to getting to know each of you.
2
EFTA01088815
BOOTHBAY
B FUND MANAGEMENT, LLC
Assets Under Management
As of April 1, 2016, Boothbay's total AUM was approximately $181 million, not including assets
from First Loss Managers.
Portfolio Review:
• Within our Multi-Strategy platform, the "Other" category was the quarter's largest contributor,
generating returns of +0.33%
• The quarterly attributions were as follows: "Quantitative," at +0.27%; "Other," at +0.33%;
"Fundamental US," at -1.85%; and "First Loss," at +0.53%
• For the first quarter of 2016, 33% of "Fundamental US", 44% of "Quantitative" and 47% of
"Other" managers were profitable
• The top five performing managers contributed 45% of the quarterly total positive return, with
the largest single manager positively contributing 13%.
• On the negative attribution side, the bottom five managers made up 49% of negative returns,
with the largest single manager negatively contributing 16%.
• As of April 2016, the Multi-Strategy platform had 27 Fundamental US Equity managers, 27
Quantitative managers, 13 "Other" managers (these figures include 10 Hybrids ), and 14 First-
Loss managers. We terminated 6 managers in the first quarter.
Risk Target and Commentary
• We averaged approximately 0.54% daily Value at Risk for the quarter, versus a target of
approximately 0.80% VaR (95% Confidence Interval — which excludes First-Loss managers).
As always, I am available to answer all investment and business inquiries. Daniel Bloom is available to
answer any questions related to financial operations.
Sincerely,
Ari Glass
Managing Member, Boothbay Fund Management LLC
By Hybrid, we are referring to accounts for which we have both a First-Loss allocation as well as a direct investment
Assumes Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies, LP, Onshore Accelerator Share Class 1A (2-year lock and 14% incentive allocation)
3
EFTA01088816
IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES
The information presented herein is confidential and proprietary, and may not be (i) used by. or on behalf of. you for any purpose other than
evaluating an initial or continued investment in Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies, LP (the "Fund"), or (ii) disclosed by, or on behalf of. you to
any third party, in each case except with the prior written consent of Boothbay Fund Management, LLC (- Boothbay").
This letter includes forward-looking statements. Although Boothbay believes that the expectations and views reflected in such statements are
reasonable, such statements are subject to a number of assumptions. risks and uncertainties which may cause actual results, performance or
achievements to be materially different from future results. performance or achievements expressed or implied by such forward-looking
statements. Forward-looking statements, and the expectations and views reflected therein, expressed in this letter may change at any time. without
notice. Prospective investors are cautioned not to invest based on these forward-looking statements.
Performance figures (which include the reinvestment of dividends. capital gains and other earnings) included herein arc based on unaudited
information. may be subject to adjustment and are shown net of fees/allocations and expenses. Results for individual investors may vary based on,
among other things. the timing of capital contributions and withdrawals.
An investment in the Fund is speculative and involves a high degree of risk. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. There
can be no assurances that the Fund will continue to have a similar return on invested capital because. among other reasons. there may be
differences in economic and market conditions, regulatory and political climate. portfolio size. investment opportunities. expenses and structure.
Accordingly. when deciding to make an investment potential investors arc urged to review carefully all disclosure documentation. including the
Fund's confidential private offering memorandum, and consult with their counsel and advisers.
Nothing herein should be interpreted to represent concentration limits. exit strategies or sector allocation guidelines. all of which are subject to
change without notice.
References to the SetP500 and any other benchmark(%) referred to herein are for illustrative purposes only. Any such benchmarks arc included
merely to show general trends in the markets in the periods indicated and arc not intended to imply that the Fund's portfolio is similar to any such
benchmarks either in composition or risk. Comparisons to benchmarks have limitation:, because natural characteristics of such benchmarks. such
as volatility. among other things. are likely to differ from those of the Fund. Boothbay does not attempt to track a benchmark and there is no
guarantee that the Fund will meet or exceed any such benchmark.
4
EFTA01088817
ℹ️ Document Details
SHA-256
2dd69fef630d81a644bb9ccc3377c16e6466a52ebbddc7ead74de61c2a2c98b0
Bates Number
EFTA01088814
Dataset
DataSet-9
Document Type
document
Pages
4
Comments 0