👁 1
💬 0
📄 Extracted Text (20,116 words)
Approved:
BOYD M. JOHNSON III
RITA GLAVIN
DANIEL STEIN
Assistant United States Attorneys
Before: HONORABLE RONALD L. ELLIS
United States Magistrate Judge
Southern District of New York
X QA8MAG .0463
LED COMPLAINT
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Violations of
18 U.S.C. § 371, 1952,
2421, 2422, 1956
MARK BRENER,
a/k/a "Michael," COUNTY OF OFFENSE:
CECIL SUWAL, NEW YORK.
a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate,"
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS,
a/k/a "Rachelle," and
TANYA HOLLANDER,
a/k/a "Tania Hollander,"
Defendants.
X
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK, ss.:
KENNETH HOSEY, being duly sworn, deposes and says that
he is a Special Agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation,
and charges as follows:
COUNT ONE
1. From in or about December 2004 to in or about
March 2008, in the Southern District of New York and elsewhere,
MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a
"Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA
HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, and others
known and unknown, unlawfully, willfully, and knowingly did
combine, conspire, confederate, and agree together and with each
other to violate Sections 1952(a)(3), 2421, and 2422(a) of Title
18, United States Code.
EFTA00190254
2. It was a part and an object of the conspiracy that
MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a
"Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA
HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, and others
known and unknown, would and did use and cause to be used
facilities in interstate commerce, to wit, cellular telephones
and e-mail, with intent to promote, manage, establish, and carry
on, and to facilitate the promotion, management, establishment
and carrying on of an unlawful activity, to wit, a business
enterprise involving prostitution offenses in violation of
applicable State law, and thereafter did perform and attempt to
perform an act to promote, manage, establish, and carry on and to
facilitate the promotion, management, establishment, and carrying
on of said unlawful activity, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Section 1952(a)(3).
3. It was a further part and an object of the
conspiracy that MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a
"Katie," a/k/a "Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle,"
and TANYA HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, and
others known and unknown, unlawfully, willfully and knowingly
would and did transport individuals in interstate and foreign
commerce with intent that such individuals engage in
prostitution, and in sexual activity for which a person can be
charged with a criminal offense, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Section 2421.
4. It was a further part and an object of the
conspiracy that MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a
"Katie," a/k/a "Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle,"
and TANYA HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, and
others known and unknown, unlawfully, willfully and knowingly
would and did persuade, induce, entice, and coerce individuals to
travel in interstate and foreign commerce to engage in
prostitution and in sexual activity for which a person can be
charged with a criminal offense, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Section 2422(a).
Overt Acts
5. In furtherance of said conspiracy and to effect
the illegal objects thereof, the following overt acts, among
others, were committed in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:
a. From in or about December 2004 through in or
about March 2008, MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," and CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendants, controlled a website
2
EFTA00190255
located at URL www.emperorsclubvip.com. that included photographs
of prostitutes' bodies, with their heads hidden, along with
hourly rates for different categories of prostitutes;
b. From in or about December 2004 through in or
about at least January 2008, MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," and
CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendants,
received applications from women seeking to work as prostitutes
with their prostitution business (hereinafter, the "Emperors
Club") at various e-mail accounts;
c. On or about January 9, 2008, MARK BRENER,
a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," and
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendants, spoke
over the telephone about offering the Emperors Club's clients the
opportunity to exercise a "buyout clause," which would permit
clients to purchase direct access to one of the Emperors Club's
prostitutes without having to contact the agency;
d. On or about January 15, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, spoke with a client of
the Emperors Club over the telephone about arranging fora
prostitute to come to his room at a hotel in New York, New York;
e. On or about January 15, 2008, a prostitute
working with the Emperors Club went to a client's hotel in New
York, New York;
f. On or about January 18, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, spoke over the telephone
with a new prostitute working with the Emperors Club who told
LEWIS that she had never "done anything like this before" and was
a "little bit nervous about it";
g. On or about January 18, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, sent an e-mail to a
potential prostitute asking her to send photographs of herself to
SUWAL;
h. On or about January 22, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, told an Emperors Club
client that he should not be concerned about sending a wire
transfer to the Emperors Club because the wire would be sent to
"QAT Consulting" so it would show up "like as a business
transaction";
i. On or about January 24, 2008, a prostitute
working with the Emperors Club went to a hotel in Los Angeles,
3
EFTA00190256
California;
j. On or about January 24, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, received an e-mail
from a potential prostitute declining to work for the Emperors
Club in part because her friend had to have sex with a client
"twice in an hour";
k. On or about January 24, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, sent an e-mail to
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, attaching
a list of the aliases used by more than 50 prostitutes working
with the Emperors Club in, among other places, New York, New
York; Los Angeles, California; Miami, Florida; London, England;
and Paris, France;
1. On or about January 24, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, sent an e-mail to a
prostitute working with the Emperors Club and asked if she would
be available on February 11, 2008, in Europe for an extended
prostitution date with a client to cost $25,000 or more.
m. On or about January 26, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, spoke with a client of
the Emperors Club over the telephone about arranging for a
prostitute to come to his room at a hotel in Los Angeles,
California;
n. On or about January 27, 2008, a prostitute
working with the Emperors Club went to a client's hotel in Los
Angeles, California;
o. On or about January 27, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, spoke with an Emperors
Club client over the telephone who asked LEWIS whether the QAT
consulting company could be traced because he had heard of
agencies like the Emperors Club getting "busted";
p. On or about January 28, 2008, MARK BRENER,
a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," and
TANYA HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, met in
the vicinity of Grand Central Terminal in New York, New York;
q. On or about January 28, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, spoke with an Emperors
Club client over the telephone about arranging for a prostitute
to travel from New York to Washington, D.C., to his hotel;
4
EFTA00190257
r. On or about January 30, 2008, MARK BRENER,
a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," and
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendants, spoke
over the telephone regarding problems with one of the Emperors
Club's prostitutes who they believed might be abusing drugs;
s. On or about January 30, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, sent TANYA HOLLANDER,
a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendant, a text message over the
telephone asking HOLLANDER to contact an Emperors Club client to
arrange an appointment with an Emperors Club prostitute in New
York on February 1, 2008;
t. On or about January 30, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, sent TANYA HOLLANDER,
a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendant, a text message over the
telephone asking HOLLANDER to send two particular prostitutes on
dates with Emperors Club clients in New York if possible, and
HOLLANDER agreed;
u. On or about January 31, 2008, TANYA HOLLANDER,
a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendant, sent CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a
"Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, a text message over the
telephone informing SUWAL that she had scheduled a date for an
Emperors Club client with an Emperors Club prostitute in Europe;
On or about February 7, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," and TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a
"Rachelle," the defendants, spoke over the telephone about the
fact that an Emperors Club client had complained that one of
their prostitutes was "more sex than sexy";
w. On or about February 11, 2008, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," and TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a
"Rachelle," the defendants, communicated via text message about
the fact that the three-day rates for two of the Emperors Club
prostitutes were $50,000 and $35,000, respectively;
x. On or about February 12, 2008, TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, spoke with an Emperors
Club client over the telephone about arranging for a prostitute
to travel from New York to Washington, D.C.; and
y. On or about February 13, 2008, an Emperors
Club prostitute traveled from New York, New York, to a hotel in
Washington, D.C.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.)
5
EFTA00190258
COUNT TWO
6. From in or about December 2004, up through and
including in or about March 2008, in the Southern District of New
York and elsewhere, MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," and CECIL
SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendants, and others
known and unknown, unlawfully, willfully, and knowingly combined,
conspired, confederated, and agreed together and with each other
to commit an offense against the United States, to wit, to
violate Title 18, United States Code, Section 1956.
7. It was a part and an object of the conspiracy that
MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," and CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate," the defendants, and others known and unknown, in an
offense involving and affecting interstate and foreign commerce,
knowing that the property involved in certain financial
transactions represented the proceeds of some form of unlawful
activity, unlawfully, willfully, and knowingly would and did
conduct such financial transactions, which in fact involved the
proceeds of specified unlawful activity, to wit, the use of
facilities in interstate commerce with the intent to promote,
manage, establish, and carry on, and to facilitate the promotion,
management, establishment, and carrying on of an unlawful
activity, to wit, a business involving prostitution offenses in
violation of applicable State law, in violation of Title 18,
United States Code, Section 1952(a)(3); interstate transportation
of individuals to engage in prostitution, in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Section 2421; and persuasion of
individuals to travel in interstate and foreign commerce to
engage in prostitution, in violation of Title 18, United States
Code, Section 2422(a), (i) with the intent to promote the
carrying on of specified unlawful activity, and (b) knowing that
the transactions were designed in whole and in part to conceal
and disguise the nature, the location, the source, the ownership,
and the control of the proceeds of specified unlawful activity,
in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections
1956(a)(1)(A)(i) and 1956(a)(1)(B)(i).
Overt Acts
8. In furtherance of the conspiracy and to effect the
illegal objects thereof, the following overt acts, among others,
were committed in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:
a. In or about December 10, 2004, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, opened a bank account
in the name of "QAT Consulting Group, Inc.";
6
EFTA00190259
b. In or about November 30, 2006, CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, opened a bank account
in the name of "QAT International, Inc.";
c. From in or about December 2004 to in or about
January 2008, MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," and CECIL SUWAL,
a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendants, received more than
$1 million in proceeds from the Emperors Club prostitution
business in bank accounts in the names of "QAT Consulting Group,
Inc.," and "QAT International, Inc.";
d. From in or about December 2004 to in or about
January 2008, CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the
defendant, wrote more than $100,000 in checks to cash from bank
accounts in the names of "QAT Consulting Group, inc.," and "QAT
International, Inc.";
e. From in or about December 2004 to in or about
January 2008, CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the
defendant, wrote more than $39,000 in checks to Protech
Consultants, a company whose bank account MARK BRENER, a/k/a
"Michael," the defendant, controlled; and
f. From in or about December 2004 to in or about
January 2008, CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the
defendant, wrote checks and sent wire transfers totaling more
than $400,000 from bank accounts in the name of "QAT Consulting
Group, Inc.," and "QAT International, Inc.," to more than 50
prostitutes working with the Emperors Club in the United States
and Europe.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 1956(h).)
9. The bases for my knowledge and for the foregoing
charges are, in part, set forth in the attached Affidavit of
Kenneth Hosey in support of the Application for Arrest Warrants,
Search Warrants, and Seizure Warrants, which is incorporated by
reference herein.
7
EFTA00190260
WHEREFORE, deponent prays that warrants be issued for
the arrests of the above-named defendants so that they may be
imprisoned or bailed, as the case may be.
KENNETH HOSEY
Special Agent
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Sworn to before me this
15 day of March, 2008.
Lt./lot WA.'
TED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
EFTA00190261
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
PpAcT€O
IN THE MATTER OF THE APPLICATION SEALED
OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT
OF. APPLICATION FOR
FOR ARREST WARRANTS, SEARCH ARREST WARRANTS,
SEARCH WARRANTS, AND
WARRANTS, AND SEIZURE WARRANTS SEIZURE WARRANTS
X
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK : ss.:
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK )
KENNETH HOSEY, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
I. INTRODUCTION
1. I have been a Special Agent with the Federal
Bureau of Investigation ("FBI") for approximately twelve years.
During that period, I have participated in investigations
involving surveillance, undercover transactions, the introduction
of undercover agents, debriefings of informants, and reviews of '
recorded conversations and documents. I have also participated
in numerous arrests.
2. I make this Affidavit in support of the following
applications:
a. An application for warrants to arrest
MICHAEL BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA
HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants;
b. An application for warrants to search the
following premises:
(i)
1 Because this location is in the District of New Jersey,
I will be requesting the search warrant from a United States
Magistrate Judge for the District of New Jersey.
EFTA00190262
(ii)
(iii)
S
c. An application for seizure warrants for the
following:
(i) All funds in
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
3. I have been involved in the investigation of this
case. This Affidavit is based upon, among other things, my
personal participation in this investigation, my conversations
with other law enforcement officers who have participated in this
investigation, my review of court-authorized wire and electronic
communications and e-mails recovered from search warrants, my
review of bank records and other documents, and my participation
in physical surveillance. Because this Affidavit is being
submitted for the limited purpose of establishing probable cause,
it does not include all of the facts that I have learned during
this investigation. Where I report statements made by others,
those statements are reported in substance and in part.
4. As explained in more detail below, there is
probable cause to believe that the defendants are organizers and
managers of a criminal organization engaged in illegal
prostitution and money-laundering activities throughout the
United States and Europe.
2
Because this location is in Brooklyn, New York, I will
be requesting the search warrant from a United States Magistrate
Judge in the Eastern District of New York.
2
EFTA00190263
II. THE EMPERORS CLUB'S PROSTITUTION CRIMES
A. Overview
5. In or about October 2007, the FBI and the United
States Internal Revenue Service-Criminal Investigative Division
("IRS-CID") began an investigation focusing on an organization
suspected of conducting prostitution and money-laundering crimes
in the United States and Europe. Through the investigation, the
FBI and IRS have determined that MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael,"
CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS,
a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander,"
the defendants, organized, managed, and operated the Emperors
Club VIP ("Emperors Club"), an international criminal
organization engaged in illegal prostitution and money-laundering
activities. BRENER, SUWAL, LEWIS, and HOLLANDER used the
Emperors Club to arrange for prostitution activity between
wealthy male clients and more than 50 prostitutes in, among other
places, New York, New York; Washington, D.C.; Los Angeles,
California; Miami, Florida;' London, England; and Paris, France.
The defendants charged the Emperors Club's clients fees ranging
from $1,000 to more than $5,500 per hour for prostitution
services.
6. Through the Emperors Club, MARK BRENER, a/k/a
"Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," TEMEKA
RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA HOLLANDER, a/k/a
"Tania Hollander;" the defendants, received more than $1 million
in illicit proceeds from their international prostitution
business. BRENER, SUWAL, LEWIS, and HOLLANDER accepted payment
3
At all times relevant to this Affidavit, New York State
law made it a crime when a person "engages or agrees or offers to
engage in sexual conduct with another person in return for a
fee." NY CLS Penal § 230.00. Similarly, District of Colombia
law made it a crime for "any person to engage in prostitution or
to solicit for prostitution," which is defined as "a sexual act
or contact with another person in return for giving or receiving
a fee," D.C. Code § 22-2701; California law made it a crime for a
person to "pay money or other valuable thing for, any person for
the purpose of prostitution," which is defined to include "any
lewd act between persons for money or other consideration,"
California Penal Code SS 266(e), 647; and Florida law made it a
crime to commit or solicit prostitution, which is defined as "the
giving or receiving of the body for sexual activity for hire,"
Florida Statutes § 796.07.
EFTA00190264
from their clients in the form of cash, American Express charges,
wire transfers, and money orders. To conceal the nature of the
Emperors Club prostitution business, MARK BRENER, a/k/a
"Michael," and CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the
defendants, received prostitution proceeds in United States bank
accounts in the names of front companies, including QAT
Consulting Group, Inc. and QAT International, Inc.
7. As demonstrated below, the evidence obtained
during this investigation includes, among other things,
statements of a confidential source who worked with the Emperors
Club; statements of an undercover officer; more than 5,000
telephone calls and text messages intercepted pursuant to court-
authorized wiretaps; more than 6,000 e-mails recovered pursuant
to court-authorized search warrants; bank records; travel and
hotel records; and physical surveillance.
8. The evidence has established that the four
defendants played different roles with respect to the criminal
activities of the Emperors Club:
a. MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," the defendant,
was the leader of the Emperors Club. BRENER had the ultimate
decision-making authority over the Emperors Club. BRENER
recruited prospective prostitutes, determined how to market the
Emperors Club's prostitutes to clients, and resolved problems
that arose with the Emperors Club's clients and prostitutes.
b. CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the
defendant, was the day-to-day organizer of the Emperors Club's
operations. SUWAL controlled the Emperors Club bank accounts,
supervised the Emperors Club's booking agents, and received
applications from the Emperors Club's prospective prostitutes.
c. TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and
TANYA HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, were
booking agents for the Emperors Club. LEWIS and HOLLANDER took
requests over the telephone from the Emperors Club's clients for
prostitution services, coordinated over the telephone with the
Emperors Club's prostitutes to carry out acts of prostitution,
and referred issues relating to payment for prostitution services
to CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant.
B. The CS,
9. I have spoken with another law enforcement officer
who has been involved in the investigation of a number of
prostitution businesses in the New York City area. The law
4
EFTA00190265
enforcement officer informed me that in the end of 2006 he spoke
with a confidential source (the "CS") who had worked as a
prostitute in New York City. The CS was immunized from
prosecution as a result of her cooperation with law enforcement.
In addition, the law enforcement officer with whom I spoke
confirmed that the CS had provided information that was reliable
and corroborated by independent evidence. The CS told the law
enforcement officer that during 2006 she worked for the Emperors
Club as a prostitute.
10. In an effort to further corroborate the
information provided by the CS, I have reviewed bank records for
account in the name of QAT
Consulting Group, Inc. (the "First QAT Account"). According to
the bank records, in 2006, the CS in fact received a check for
more than $1,000 from the First QAT Account. As discussed in
further detail below, the defendants have directed clients of the
Emperors Club to make payments for prostitution services to the
First QAT Acc and also to a second bank account at/Mabank
account in the name of QAT International, Inc. (the
"Second QAT Account").
C. The Undercover
11. In the course of this investigation, I have worked
with an agent acting in an undercover capacity (the
"Undercover"). The Undercover posed as a potential client of the
Emperors Club prostitution business, and made arrangements over
the telephone with TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the
defendant, for an appointment with an Emperors Club prostitute.
He then coordinated over e-mail with CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, to make a deposit of more than
$1,000 towards the appointment in the Second QAT Account.
12. The Undercover initially went on the Internet and
accessed a website located at URL www.emperorsclubvip.com. (the
"Website"). The Website included photographs of Emperors Club
prostitutes' bodies, with their faces hidden, along with hourly
rates for different categories of prostitutes. The Website
ranked the prostitutes using a ranking system from one to seven
diamonds, and charged hourly rates according to the assigned
ranking. For example, according to the Website, the Emperors
Club charged $1,000 per hour for a three-diamond prostitute, and
$3,100 per hour for a seven-diamond prostitute. The Website
offered the Emperors Club's most valued clients "membership" in
the "Icon Club," a status which allowed the clients to access
restricted areas of the Website and permitted them to schedule
appointments for illegal prostitution services with the most
highly-ranked prostitutes whose fees started at $5,500 per hour.
5
EFTA00190266
According to the Website, in certain circumstances, the Emperors
Club also offered its clients the opportunity to exercise a "buy-
out clause," which permitted them to purchase direct access to
one of the Emperors Club's prostitutes without having to contact
the agency. The Website listed (the "2114
Number") as one of the numbers for clients to use to contact the
Emperors Club.°
13. On or about October 20, 2007, at approximately
9:30 p.m., the Undercover placed a call to the 2114 Number, which
I have determined from toll records was forwarded to a cellular
telephone assigned call number _6587 (the "6587
Number"). The call was answered by TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a
"Rachelle," the defendant.5 During the conversation, the
Undercover and LEWIS discussed an appointment the Undercover
wanted to arrange for October 25, 2007. The Undercover explained
that he was hoping to have a "good night" for himself. LEWIS
asked the Undercover which particular woman he wanted to see, to
which the Undercover responded that all the women on the Website
were "beautiful." The Undercover requested an appointment with
"Helena" - one of the women depicted on the Website - but LEWIS
told him that "Helena" was "based in London." The Undercover
then asked for an appointment with "Drew," to which LEWIS
4
As discussed below, I have determined that telephone
calls placed to the 2114 Number were typically forwarded to
various cellular telephones used by CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA
HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants.
5
My belief that the person using the 6587 Number in this
and other calls summarized above was LEWIS is based on the
following: First, an IRS-CID agent working on this case has
reviewed bank records for the First QAT Account for the period
December 10, 2004, through January 2008. The IRS-CID agent has
determined that during this time period approximately $53,473.00
worth of checks were written from the First QAT Account to
"Rachelle Lewis," a portion of which were negotiated through an
account at Sia in the name of According
to records obtained from the current address for the
account holder of the account is
On February 28, 2008,
another a cer spo e with LEWIS, who identified
herself as "Tameka Lewis," and saw her enter at
Second, during calls intercepted over the 6587
Number, LEWI consistently identified herself over the telephone
as either "Rachelle" or "Temeka."
6
EFTA00190267
responded that "Drew" was based in New York, but had very limited
availability. The Undercover stated that he was looking for
someone who was "physically very attractive" and had a "fun
personality.x' LEWIS stated that, based on the women the
Undercover had identified, it sounded like the Undercover was not
necessarily interested in "that model look," but maybe someone "a
little curvier than a model." After the Undercover agreed, LEWIS
said that "Drew" was a "great choice." It "Drew" was not
available, LEWIS said she would recommend "Raquel," whom she
described as a "brunette" who was "beautiful . . . All-American
. . very clean, . . . very fresh." She explained that "Raquel"
and "Drew" had "similar body types," though "Raquel" was
"probably a little bit bustier on top." LEWIS told the
Undercover that for "Drew" there was a "two-hour, introductory
rate" of $2,000, and that "Raquel's" hourly rate was $1,500 for
the first two hours, with a discount to $1,200 for the third
hour. The conversation ended with the Undercover asking LEWIS
for a follow-up call to confirm the arrangements, which LEWIS
promised to do. LEWIS further stated that she could be reached
at either the " Inumber" (believed to be a reference to the
2114 Number) or t e "347 number" (believed to be a reference to
the 6587 Number), and that the Undercover could always reach her
directly at the "347 number."
14. On or about October 22, 2007, at approximately
2:33 p.m., the Undercover received a call from TEMEKA RACHELLE '
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant. During the call, LEWIS
and the Undercover confirmed an appointment for the Undercover to
meet "Raquel." LEWIS told the Undercover that he would have to
meet "Raquel" at a "private location just . . . for the beginning
of the appointment . . . where she would collect the fee," and
suggested that they meet at "a hotel or a private home." The
Undercover asked if there was another way he could handle the
payment of the fee, and LEWIS responded that he could either "pay
cash," use his American Express card, or pay by wire transfer.
The Undercover expressed a preference for a wire transfer, and
LEWIS told him she would send him the necessary information,
asking if she could send it to him by text message.
15. On or about October 22, 2007, at approximately
3:24 p.m., the Undercover called the 2114 Number, which was
' The Undercover also stated that, in the long term, he
wanted to discuss "other things" with LEWIS, such as, hiring a
group of women to entertain his clients. LEWIS said that
"certainly could be arranged," and that "our models are the types
of women who can handle themselves well in any situation."
7
EFTA00190268
forwarded to another cellular telephone, and spoke to TEMEKA
RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant. During the
call, LEWIS stated that she had spoken to "the office," and that
they preferred to send him the wire transfer information by e-
mail. The Undercover provided LEWIS with his e-mail address.
16. The Undercover subsequently received an e-mail
from an e-mail address identified as
"reservationsWemperorsclubvip.com." The e-mail provided the
Undercover with instructions for paying his fee by wire transfer
and was signed by "Katie," which I believe to be an alias used by
CECIL SUWAL, the defendant. In the e-mail, "Katie" identified
the Second QAT Account as the bank account where the Undercover
should send his wire transfer. The Undercover later wire
transferred more than $1,000 to the Second QAT Account.'
17. On or about November 29, 2007, at approximately
3:47 p.m., the Undercover called TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a
"Rachelle," the defendant, on the 6587 Number. During the call,
the Undercover asked to reschedule his appointment with "Raquel."
LEWIS told the Undercover that "Raquel" had moved back to Los
Angeles, California. The Undercover then asked if "Raquel" would
travel back from California to New York to be with him. LEWIS
stated that "Raquel" would travel, but it would have to be a
lengthy appointment. LEWIS told the Undercover that she would
have to check with "Raquel" about her availability. During a
later call on November 29, 2007, over the 6587 Number, LEWIS
confirmed to the Undercover that Raquel would travel to New
Jersey for an appointment with the Undercover.
D. The Intercepted Communications And Seized E-Mails
18. Based in part on the information provided by the
CS and the Undercover, described above, on or about January 8,
2008, the Honorable Charles S. Haight, United States District
Judge for the Southern District of New York, authorized the
interception of telephone calls and text messages over the 6587
Number. On or about February 7, 2008, authorization expired, but
was renewed on or about February 11, 2008, by the Honorable
Gerard E. Lynch. On or about January 23, 2008, based in part on
The Undercover later told TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a
"Rachelle," the defendant, that he had to reschedule his October
25, 2007, appointment. As discussed above, the FBI relied on the
Undercover's recorded conversations with LEWIS, among other
evidence, to support an application for court authorization to
wiretap the 6587 Number.
8
EFTA00190269
communications intercepted over the 6587 Number, the Honorable
Leonard B. Sand, United States District Judge for the Southern
District of New York, authorized the interception of telephone
calls and text messages over the cellular telephone assigned call
number 4IIIIIIII/3390 (the "3390 Number"), which was used by
CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," and MARK BRENER, a/k/a
"Michael," the defendants, to operate the Emperors Club and to
make strategic decisions regarding its prostitution and money-
laundering activities. On or about February 21, 2008, the
Honorable M. McKenna, United States District Judge for
the Southern District of New York, re-authorized the interception
of telephone calls and text messages over the 3390 Number. To
date, the FBI has intercepted more than 5,000 telephone calls and
text messages over the 6587 Number and the 3390 Number.
19. On or about January 25, 2008, based on wiretap
interceptions and other evidence developed during the
investigation, the FBI obtained a search warrant from the
Honorable Gabriel W. Gorenstein, United States Magistrate Judge
for the Southern District of New York, for the content of the e-
mail account entitled "[email protected]" (the
"Emperors Club E-Mail Account"), which was used primarily by MARK
BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," and CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a
"Kate," the defendants, to recruit new prostitutes for the
Emperors Club. As a result of the search warrant, the FBI
obtained more than 6,000 e-mails relating to the Emperors Club's
operations.
20. The intercepted telephone calls and text messages,
combined with the recovered e-mails, demonstrate that MARK
BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a
"Kate," TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," and TANYA
HOLLANDER, a/k/a "Tania Hollander," the defendants, collectively
managed the prostitution activities of the Emperors Club. These
intercepted wire and electronic communications also confirmed
that the defendants were, among other things: (1) making various
strategic decisions regarding the Emperors Club's criminal
operations; (2) using cellular telephones and e-mail to promote
prostitution in the United States and Europe; and (3) conspiring
with certain clients to transport prostitutes interstate for the
purposes of prostitution.
1. The Emperors Club's Operational Issues
21. During a number of intercepted telephone calls the
text messages, and recovered e-mails, the defendants discussed
various strategic issues relating to the Emperors Club. These
issues included relationships with the Emperors Club's clients,
9
EFTA00190270
the recruitment, marketing, and advertising of Emperors Club's
prostitutes, hourly rates and other payment issues, and problems
that arose with the Emperors Club's prostitutes and clients. A
number of these intercepted telephone calls and text messages and
recovered e-mails are summarized below.
a. The "Buv-Out" Option
22. On January 10, 2008, at approximately 8:44 p.m.,'
MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," the defendant,' using the 3390
Number, called TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the
defendant, at the 6587 Number. During the call, BRENER and LEWIS
discussed a business arrangement, which they referred to as a
"buy-out," by which a client of the Emperors Club could "buy out"
a prostitute, and thereby arrange appointments with her without
having to go through the Emperors Club. At one point in the
conversation, BRENER handed the telephone to CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a
All times are Eastern Standard Time unless otherwise
indicated.
9
My belief that the person using the 3390 Number in this
and other calls summarized above, and using the telephone
assigned call numbersms0937 (the "0937 Number") in other
calls summarized above, was BRENER is based on, among other
things, the following: First, the 3390 Number and the 0937
Number are both subscribed to CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a
"Kate," the defendant, at
Time arner Cable records reflect
that the account of MARK BRENER also is registered to BRENER at
the address. Second, in
intercepted calls over the 3390 Number and the 0937 Number, an
individual referred to as "Michael" discussed traveling with
SUWAL to meet with other co-conspirators. Other FBI agents then
observed BRENER with SUWAL on surveillance meeting with other co-
conspirators. Moreover, after a series of intercepted calls
involving "Michael" and SUWAL, on January 28, 2008, I observed
individuals resembling BRENER and SUWAL inside their."'"
AIIIIIIIminivan near the vicinity of Grand Central Terminal in
Manhattan. Also, a New York City Police Department Officer, at
the FBI's request, identified the man driving the Honda Odyssey
as BRENER. As a result, I believe that the "Michael" speaking
over the 3390 Number and the 0937 Number during the course of the
wiretaps was BRENER.
10
EFTA00190271
"Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant,'" who continued discussing
the same subject with LEWIS; in particular, SUWAL and LEWIS
discussed a specific client who had expressed interest in such an
arrangement, and the fact that they needed to find out how much
such an arrangement was worth for that client. SUWAL indicated
that during a conversation the day before they had disregarded
this client's potential for the "buy out." SUWAL then stated:
"[O]n second thought . . . why would we completely disregard him.
[I]f . . . maybe a good deal could come of it, . . . maybe it
would come more [money) than . . . what we're currently seeing
and receiving from him. So . . . when he calls asking for
`Raquel' [believed to be the alias of a prostitute], he wants to
see her again, again, again, . . . you can always say, `You know,
you may be interested in privately dating her which is when . . .
you contact her directly . . . and not necessarily going through
the agency.'' (Call 865C).
b. Advertising
23. On January 12, 2008, at approximately 8:59 p.m.,
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, using the
6587 Number, called MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael," the defendant,
at the 0937 Number. During the call, BRENER and LEWIS discussed
the Emperors Club's prostitution operations in Los Angeles,
California. LEWIS told BRENER: "I don't know if, if you're gonna
io My belief that the person using the 3390 Number in this
and other calls summarized above, and using the 0937 Number in
other calls summarized above, was SUWAL is based on, among other
things, the following: First, the 3390 Number and the 0937
Number are subscribed in the name "Cecil Suwal." Second, on
January 17, 2008, there were calls between the 3390 Number and
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, on the
6587 Number, regarding meeting in New Jersey. Around the time of
these calls, other FBI agents and I were following thee
inivan and observed both MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael,"
the defendant, and a female I believed to be SUWAL inside.
Another FBI agent then observed LEWIS enter the
with SUWAL and BRENER. Another FBI agent compared a river s
license photograph of SUWAL with the person who was inside the
fiffliand believed that the person was SUWAL. Third,
during February 2008, the FBI intercepted calls over the 3390
Number during which the speaker said that she and "Michael,"
believed to be a reference to BRENER, were traveling to London.
From law enforcement records, I have determined that during
February 2008 SUWAL and BRENER in fact traveled to London under
their true names.
11
EFTA00190272
be advertising but . . . it's just been really, really slow in LA
. . . We have a lot of girls there now . . . we need calls."
BRENER said that he understood, and thanked LEWIS. (Call 1507R).
• c. Recruitment Of Prostitutes
24. On January 18, 2008, CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, sent an e-mail from the Emperors
Club E-Mail Account to a potential prostitute. In the e-mail,
SUWAL stated: "It was a pleasure meeting you last night. If you
are having trouble emailing the pictures perhaps we can just meet
up, take them and then return them to you the next day after we
scan them into the computer. You can also feel free to email any
that are `email-able' now. . . ."
25. On January 24, 2008, CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie,"
a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, received an e-mail at the Emperors
Club E-Mail Account from a potential prostitute. In the e-mail,
the potential prostitute wrote:
Hi, I have just spoke to a friend of mine who done
[sic] her first job for you . . . Unfortunately I
wasn't very happy to find out that its only 500 ph +
over 50% commission fees . . . I was aware of 50% but
didn't know the price was 500 . . . This is a kind of
money I make very easily in photoshoots and the reason
I wanted to join your site to make an extra money . .
The other think [sic] I was little bit shock and
confuse that she had a sex with him twice in an hour
and without her [sic] taking her out for dinner before.
. So I am very sorry I don't think this is my kind of
thing. I was told by your assistant in London this is
more like a dating agency than an escort. But to
provide sex for £500 an hour, I just thing [sic] this
is not a price I would ever consider of doing it for. .
d. Marketing
26. On January 19, 2008, MARK BRENER, a/k/a "Michael,"
the defendant, using the 0937 Number, called TEMEKA RACHELLE
LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, at the 6587 Number.
During the call, BRENER asked LEWIS if his "intervention" was
needed regarding the unavailability of a girl for an Emperors
Club client in Miami, Florida. LEWIS told BRENER no, and listed
three prostitutes who were working in Miami. BRENER commented
that one of the prostitutes "looks like [a] butcher in my
opinion," and told LEWIS that he was not sure if LEWIS could
12
EFTA00190273
t
"market this girl." BRENER and LEWIS then discussed the other
two Miami-based prostitutes. BRENER asked LEWIS if the Miami
client sounded like a rich person, and BRENER indicated that he
was thinking of offering the client "membership." BRENER
commented: "[I]f he's rich guy . . . we send or fly somebody to
them, right?" BRENER and LEWIS then discussed coaching another
prostitute, and LEWIS suggested that "Katie," a reference to
CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," ,the defendant, should
call her. LEWIS stated that she doubted that the prostitute they
were discussing would ever be an "Icon" model. (Call 2344R).
27. On February 11, 2008, at approximately 12)53 p.m.,
CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate," the defendant, using
the 3390 Number, sent a text message to TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS,
a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, at the 6587 Number, stating:
"[C]hrissy is at $2100/hr." (Call 3582C). LEWIS responded: "New
pix or same ones?" (Call 3585C). SUWAL stated: "Same ones . . .
she'll have new ones soon but so far the ones she 1st gave are
the best." (Call 3588C). LEWIS responded: "Ok." (Call 3598C).
SUWAL, using the 3390 Number, sent another text message to LEWIS
at the 6587 Number, stating: "[S]omeone asked what her 3 day rate
was. I told him about 50,000 & that emilys was about 35,000 in
case he calls." (Call 3594C). LEWIS replied: "Ok." (Call
3598C).
e. Availability Of Prostitutes
28. On January 18, 2008, at approximately 5:41 p.m.,
TEMEKA RACHELLE LEWIS, a/k/a "Rachelle," the defendant, using the
6587 Number, received a call from a new prostitute working with
the Emperors Club. LEWIS and the new prostitute discussed an
upcoming date that LEWIS had scheduled for her in Los Angeles,
California. The new prostitute told LEWIS that she had talked to
"Katie," a reference to CECIL SUWAL, a/k/a "Katie," a/k/a "Kate,"
the defendant, but she had never done anything like this before
and was a little bit nervous about it. LEWIS said that she would
let the client know that this was her first appointment, and
indicated that "Katie" could best answer how to handle oneself on
an appointment. The new prostitute was concerned because she
wanted to be more anonymous, and did not want to be pictured on
the Website in part because of her family background. LEWIS told
the new prostitute that it was in her interest to have pictures
on the Website, and commented: "There are some pictures where I
think that even if you knew who the person was, you couldn't
really identify [them]." LEWIS suggested that when "Katie"
cropped the pictures, she should tell "Katie" that she did not
want anything above the chin. The new prostitute and LEWIS
discussed the possibility of the new prostitute becoming an
13
ℹ️ Document Details
SHA-256
87e1468c3fc5840040c1f2a3a3b7362788ef449669ea0a426f8f605ec0eaaeb7
Bates Number
EFTA00190254
Dataset
DataSet-9
Type
document
Pages
55
💬 Comments 0