gov.uscourts.nysd.447706.1058.4.pdf

giuffre-maxwell 27 pages 2,014 words document
👁 1 💬 0
📄 Extracted Text (2,014 words)
Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 1 of 27

                    Exhibit C
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 2 of 27

                                ' &%&&%%&$&!'$&
                               %!'&$ %&$&! )*!$

 +'$" *'
 
          &:/7<B744
                                                               7D7:1B7=<$=  1D "&
    D
    
     "$'(%,).
    
        343<2/<B 

    "$'(%,).
    
        =C<B3@1:/7;&:/7<B744
    
    D

    +'$" *'
    
        =C<B3@1:/7;343<2/<B 

                            " &H%!&! % $%"! %%
          &!  &H%$%&$#'%&!$"$!'&! !!' &%

           &C@AC/<B B= 'C:3A  /<2  =4 B63 323@/: 'C:3A =4 7D7: &@=132C@3 &:/7<B744 +7@57<7/

    7C44@3 0G /<2 B6@=C56 63@ 1=C<A3: >@=D723A B63 4=::=E7<5 '3A>=<A3A /<2 %0831B7=<A B=

    343<2/<B:/<3@A6=E7BHLA7@AB'3?C3AB4=@&@=2C1B7=<=4=1C;3<BAJ'3?C3ABAK=@J'&AK

    /A4=::=EA

                                           $!&! %
                                                         
                  &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63G/BB3;>BB=7;>=A3=0:75/B7=<A

=<&:/7<B74403G=<2B6=A37;>=A32=@/CB6=@7H320GB63323@/:'C:3A=47D7:&@=132C@3B63"=1/:

7D7:'C:3A=4B63(=CB63@<7AB@71B=4$3E-=@9=@/<G/>>:71/0:3=@23@=4B63=C@B 

        Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 3 of 27

                 &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63G@3:G=<2347<7B7=<A=@@C:3A=4

1=<AB@C1B7=<B6/B/@30@=/23@B6/<B63C<74=@;2347<7B7=<A1=<B/7<327<"=1/:7D7:'C:3   

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63GCA3=@1=<B/7<E=@2A=@>6@/A3A

B6/B/@3D/5C3/<2 =@/;075C=CA 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63GA339B6327A1:=AC@3=4

7<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A<=BE7B67<B63A1=>3=4323@/:'C:3=47D7:&@=132C@3 <=B@3:3D/<B;/B3@7/:

=@<313AA/@GB=B67A/1B7=</<2<=B:793:GB=:3/2B=B6327A1=D3@G=4/2;7AA70:33D723<13 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB63GA3397<4=@;/B7=<<=B@3/A=</0:G7<

&:/7<B744LA>=AA3AA7=<1CAB=2G=@1=<B@=: 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABA7<A=4/@/AB63GA339B6327A1:=AC@3=47<4=@;/B7=<B6/B

7AAC0831BB=B63B3@;A=41=<4723<B7/:7BG=@<=<27A1:=AC@3/5@33;3<BAE7B6B67@2>/@B73A/<2 =@E=C:2

D7=:/B3B63>@7D/1G7<B3@3ABA=4=B63@A )=B633FB3<BB6/B&:/7<B744/5@33A=@7A=@23@32B=27A1:=A3

7<4=@;/B7=<7<@3A>=<A3B=B63A3'3?C3ABAAC1627A1:=AC@3A6/::03AC0831BB=/<21=<B7<53<BC>=<

/>>@=>@7/B3<=B713B=/<2 =@1=<A3<B4@=;AC16B67@2>/@B73A 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB63GA339>3@A=</:/<2>@7D/B3

7<4=@;/B7=<=4/<G7<27D72C/:B6327A1:=AC@3=4E67167A>@=6707B320G4323@/:AB/B3=@:=1/::/E@C:3

=@@35C:/B7=< 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63G/@3C<@3/A=</0:G1C;C:/B7D3

2C>:71/B7D3=@@32C<2/<B 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63G/@327A>@=>=@B7=</B3B=B63

<332A=4B631/A3 

                 &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63G1/::4=@B6327A1:=AC@3=4

7<4=@;/B7=<:3/@<324@=;2=1C;3<BA>@3>/@327</<B717>/B7=<=4:7B75/B7=<B6/B1=<AB7BCB3A=@@34:31BA

/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1BB6/B1=<B/7<A>@7D7:3532/BB=@<3G1:73<B1=;;C<71/B7=<A7<1:C27<5>@7D7:3532

         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 4 of 27

7<4=@;/B7=<=@2=1C;3<BAA6/@32E7B63<B7B73AE7B6E6716&:/7<B7446=:2A=@63:2/1=;;=<7<B3@3AB

=@B6/B7A=B63@E7A3>@=B31B324@=;27A1:=AC@3C<23@/>>:71/0:3>@7D7:353A:/EA=@@C:3A 

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABA=<B635@=C<2AB6/BB63G/@3=D3@0@=/2B=B633FB3<B

B6/BB63GA339>@7D7:35321=;;C<71/B7=<AAC16/AB631=;;C<71/B7=<A0G/<203BE33<&:/7<B744/<2

63@1=C<A3:A7<13B6347:7<5=4B63=;>:/7<B (C16/23;/<2>:/13A/<C<2C30C@23<=<&:/7<B744

031/CA37BE=C:2@3?C7@363@B=:=5D=:C;7<=CA/<23D3@7<1@3/A7<5>@7D7:35321=;;C<71/B7=<A

03BE33<&:/7<B744/<263@1=C<A3:/AB63>@=A31CB7=<=4B67A1/A31=<B7<C3A "793E7A3&:/7<B744=0831BA

B=B63'3?C3ABA/A=D3@:G0C@23<A=;3B=B633FB3<BB63GE=C:2@3?C7@3:=557<5D=:C;7<=CA>@7D7:3532

2=1C;3<BA03BE33<&:/7<B744/<263@1=C<A3:@3:/B32B= '$(*)/A3$=  1D 

',((=CB63@<7AB@71B=4$3E-=@9! "!! "(!&&&%/A3$=  

 +#/@@/(=CB63@<7AB@71B=4:=@72/ $+ )$%!' %%(!

    $%")&,/A3$=           (3D3<B33<B6 C2717/:7@1C7B@=E/@2=C<BG:=@72/

/<2! ""($+ #%&!/A3$=  +#/@@/ =6<A=<(=CB63@<7AB@71B

=4:=@72/ /A32=<B67A=0831B7=<&:/7<B744=0831BAB=/<22=3A<=B7<B3<2B=>@=2C13/>@7D7:353:=5

=463@1=;;C<71/B7=<AE7B61=C<A3:@3:/B32B=B63>@=A31CB7=<=4B67A1B7=</<2B631/A3A723<B74732

/0=D3 

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB63GA339>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:32=1C;3<BA

B6/B/@3/A@3/27:G723<B747/0:3/<2=0B/7</0:30G343<2/<B/A&:/7<B744 

              &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB63G1/::4=@B63>@=2C1B7=<=4

2=1C;3<BA=@7<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A/:@3/2G7<B63>=AA3AA7=<1CAB=2G=@1=<B@=:=4B63343<2/<B 

              &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63A3'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63G/@32C>:71/B7D3=42=1C;3<BA

=@AC0>=3</AB6/BE3@3A3@D32=@E7::03A3@D320G=@=<=B63@3<B7B73A7<1:C27<50CB<=B:7;7B32B=

B63(C0>=3</A3@D32=<=73A(167::3@:3F<3@=<313;03@          

                                                  
        Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 5 of 27

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63347<7B7=<A=4J-=CKJ-=C@K/<2J7C44@3K/A=D3@0@=/2

>/@B71C:/@:GB=B633FB3<BB63G7<B3<2B=AE33>&:/7<B744LA1=C<A3:7<B=B632347<7B7=< =<A7AB3<BE7B6

"=1/:7D7:'C:3  &:/7<B744E7::1=<AB@C3B63A3B3@;AB=3F1:C23=B63@<=</447:7/B32>3@A=<A

/1B7<5/BB6327@31B7=<C<23@B631=<B@=:=4=@=<036/:4=4&:/7<B744 

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63347<7B7=<=4J-=C@BB=@<3GAK031/CA37B7<1:C23A</;3A=4

/BB=@<3GAB6/B2=<=B/<26/D3<=B@3>@3A3<B3263@ 

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63347<7B7=<=4J1=<13@<7<5K/A=D3@0@=/2/<2E7::1=<AB@C3B63

>6@/A31=<A7AB3<BE7B6"=1/:7D7:'C:3   

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=<AB@C1B7=< B=B633FB3<B7B/BB3;>BAB=>:/13=0:75/B7=<A=<63@B=

=0B/7<2=1C;3<BAB6/B/@3<=B7<63@1CAB=2G=@1=<B@=:0G1=;>3::7<5>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B67@2>/@B73A 

               &:/7<B744=0831BAB=<AB@C1B7=<A  <G>@=2C1B7=<AE7::03;/237</11=@2/<13E7B6

/>@=B=1=:B=03/5@332C>=</;=<5B63>/@B73A 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=<AB@C1B7=<A   /<2 /AC<2C:G0C@23<A=;3/AB63GA339B=>:/13

=0:75/B7=<A=<&:/7<B744A>/<<7<5/     G3/@>3@7=2 

                &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B63'3?C3ABAB=B633FB3<BB6/BB63GCA3B3@;A<=B2347<327<B63

J347<7B7=<A K)63=0831B7=<AB=/<G2347<32B3@;/@37<1=@>=@/B320G@343@3<13/B3D3@G7<AB/<13=4

B63CA3=4B6/BB3@;7<B63'3?C3ABA 

                &:/7<B744LA7<D3AB75/B7=</<223D3:=>;3<B=4/::4/1BA/<217@1C;AB/<13A@3:/B7<5B=B67A

/1B7=<7A=<5=7<5 )63A3@3A>=<A3A/<2=0831B7=<A/@3;/23E7B6=CB>@38C2713B=/<2/@3<=B/

E/7D3@=4&:/7<B744LA@756BAB=@3:G=<=B63@4/1BA=@2=1C;3<BA<=B>@=2C1327<@3A>=<A3B=B63A3

'3?C3ABA 

               <@3A>=<27<5B=B63A3'3?C3ABA&:/7<B7442=3A<=BE/7D3=@7<B3<2B=E/7D363@@756B

B==0831BB=B63/2;7AA7=<=4/<G/<AE3@7<3D723<13/B/<G>@=13327<563/@7<5=@B@7/: &:/7<B744

                                                     
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 6 of 27

@3A3@D3AB63@756BB==0831B=</::5@=C<2AB=B637<B@=2C1B7=<=4/<G3D723<131=D3@32=@@343@@32B=

7<B63@3A>=<A3A03:=E 

               &:/7<B7443F>@3AA:G@3A3@D3AB63@756BB=AC>>:3;3<B1:/@74G@3D7A3=@1=@@31B/<G=@/::

=4B63=0831B7=<A63@37</<2B=/AA3@B/227B7=</:=0831B7=<A=@>@7D7:353A7<=<3=@;=@3AC0A3?C3<B

AC>>:3;3<B/:@3A>=<A3A 

               G/5@337<5B=A3/@164=@/<2>@=2C132=1C;3<BA7<@3A>=<A3B=/@3?C3AB&:/7<B7447A

<=B@3>@3A3<B7<5B6/BAC162=1C;3<BA/1BC/::G3F7AB=@1/<03723<B747324=::=E7<5/@3/A=</0:3/<2

27:753<BA3/@16 

               G=0831B7<5B=/@3?C3AB&:/7<B7447A<=B@3>@3A3<B7<5B6/BAC162=1C;3<BA/1BC/::G

3F7AB=@1/<03723<B747324=::=E7<5/@3/A=</0:3/<227:753<BA3/@16 

                                 %"$%"! %% !&! %

                 99<0B:2;A@A5.AF<B0<;@B9A21<??232??21A<6;.;@D2?6;42?@5<D6AGH@

    6?@A%2A<3;A2??<4.A<?62@

          $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=

B67A'3?C3AB031/CA3343<2/<BLA<B3@@=5/B=@73AD7=:/B3"=1/:'C:3  &:/7<B7444C@B63@=0831BA

B=B67A'3?C3AB7<B6/B7BA339A7<4=@;/B7=<>@=B31B320GB63/BB=@<3G1:73<B>@7D7:353/<2B63

/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B74427@31BA343<2/<BB=&:/7<B744LA

<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A/<22=1C;3<BAA3@D32=<313;03@            /<2313;03@        /<2B63

:7AB=4&:/7<B744LA;3271/:>@=D723@AA3@D32=<313;03@          

                  99<0B:2;A@.;1<::B;60.A6<;@0<;02?;6;4*<B?.9924.A6<;@6;A52

    <:=9.6;A6;A56@0A6<;

          $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=

    B67A'3?C3AB/A=D3@0@=/2 AE@7BB3<B67A'3?C3ABE=C:2AE33>7<>=B3<B7/::GA1=@3A=4
                                                   
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 7 of 27

    2=1C;3<BAE7B6:7BB:3B=<=@3:3D/<13B=B6327A>CB327AAC3A7<B67A1/A3/<2E=C:27;>=A3

    0C@23<A=<&:/7<B744B6/B/@327A>@=>=@B7=</B3B=B63<332A=4B67A1/A3 &:/7<B7444C@B63@=0831BAB=

    B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7B1/::A4=@B63>@=2C1B7=<=4>@7D7:35321=;;C<71/B7=<A/<2 =@

    2=1C;3<BA>@=B31B320GB63/BB=@<3G1:73<B/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B=@=B63@/>>:71/0:3>@7D7:353A 

    &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7B1/::A4=@B63>@=2C1B7=<=4>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3

    2=1C;3<BAAC16/A<3EAAB=@73A;327/@3>=@BA3B1 B6/B/@3/A@3/27:G/D/7:/0:3B=343<2/<B/A

    B63G/@3B=&:/7<B744 <@3A>=<27<5B=B67A'3?C3AB&:/7<B744E7::<=B03:=557<5>@7D7:3532

    1=;;C<71/B7=<AB6/B>=AB2/B3B6347:7<5=4B63=;>:/7<B=@>@=2C17<5>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3

    ;/B3@7/:AAC16/AB6=A317B327<B63=;>:/7<B 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/B/A>/@B=463@

<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A&:/7<B744>@=2C132B=343<2/<BB633<B7@3BG=463@2=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<7<

    '$(*)/<263@<=<>/@BG>@=2C1B7=<=42=1C;3<BA7< )$%( $%")&, <

/227B7=<&:/7<B744>@=2C132/1=>G=463@23>=A7B7=<A7<B63 '$(*)1/A3@31=@2A4@=;

#/@/"/5=4:756B:=5A/<2B63<=<>/@BG>@=2C1B7=<4@=;+71B7;A'34CA3(7:3<137<B63 '$

(*);/BB3@ <A3/@167<54=@/<2>@=2C17<5@3A>=<A7D33;/7:A7<B63 '$(*)

;/BB3@E6716E3@37<1:C2327<B63>@=2C1B7=</:@3/2G>@=D7232B=343<2/<B&:/7<B7443;>:=G32

A3/@16B3@;AB6/BE=C:21/>BC@32=1C;3<BA/<21=;;C<71/B7=<A7<63@3;/7:/11=C<B@3:/B32B=

343<2/<B =@3F/;>:3&:/7<B744CA32B634=::=E7<5A3/@16B3@;AJ:/<KJ3@A6K/<2J K

)6CA&:/7<B744E7B6B633F13>B7=<A<=B3203:=E=0831BAB=A3/@167<563@3;/7:A/<3E4=@B63B7;3

>3@7=2>@7=@B=C5CAB         E63<63@3;/7:E/A1=::31B324=@B63 '$(*);/BB3@/A

@3A>=<A7D3<=<>@7D7:35323;/7:AE=C:2/:@3/2G03>/@B=4B63>@7=@*)>@=2C1B7=<E6716

6/A/:@3/2G033<>@=D7232B=343<2/<B =E3D3@&:/7<B7447AE7::7<5AC0831BB=/</5@33;3<B=<

/</>>@=>@7/B3>@=2C1B7=<>@=B=1=:/<2A3/@16B3@;AB=C>2/B3B63A3>@7=@>@=2C1B7=<AE7B6

@3A>=<A7D3<=<>@7D7:35322=1C;3<BA/<21=;;C<71/B7=<AB6/BE3@337B63@1@3/B32=@=0B/7<32

                                                     
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 8 of 27

A7<13B6=A3>@=2C1B7=<AE3@3;/23/<2B=2=/<=<2/B3:7;7B32A3/@164=@3;/7:A/<2

/BB/16;3<BA1=<B/7<7<5B634=::=E7<5A3/@16B3@;AB6/BE3@3<=B7<1:C2327<B63A3/@16>@=B=1=:7<

B63 '$(*)1/A3I/@;3@'/<A=;3'=2@75C3H=G:/<@=E<@C19.3753@

!3AA:3@:3F/<23@"/<5'37B3@(B@/BB=</@/9/<2!3AA:3@B/93<4@=;B63:7AB=47<27D72C/:A

723<B747327<343<2/<BLA'3?C3AB$=  </227B7=</AAC;7<5B63=C@B5@/<BA:3/D3&:/7<B744

E7::>@=2C13B=343<2/<BB632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<@3137D324@=;67A:/7<3#/FE3::7<B63

    '$(*);/BB3@E67167A1C@@3<B:GAC0831BB=B63>@=B31B7D3=@23@7<B6/B1/A3 &:/7<B744LA

E7::7<5<3AAB=@C<B63A3A3/@16B3@;A/<2>@=2C13;/B3@7/:A4@=;B63 '$(*);/BB3@

A6=C:2<=B031=<AB@C32/A/</5@33;3<BB6/B/<G=4B63B3@;A=@;/B3@7/:A/@3@3:3D/<B 

                 99<0B:2;A@.;1<::B;60.A6<;@?232?2;0216;F<B?<:=9.6;A<?

    ;@D2?@A<;A2??<4.A<?62@

          $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=

B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7BA339AB63>@=2C1B7=<=4>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3;/B3@7/:AE6716343<2/<B

1/</113AA0/A32=<B6317B/B7=<A/<2@343@3<13A>@=D72320G&:/7<B7447<63@=;>:/7<B/<2E6716

2=<=B@3?C7@3>@=2C1B7=<0G&:/7<B744 &:/7<B744:793E7A3=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7B

1/::A4=@B63>@=2C1B7=<=4;/B3@7/:AB6/B/@3/:@3/2G7<343<2/<BLA>=AA3AA7=<AC16/A67A=E<

23>=A7B7=<B3AB7;=<G1=@@3A>=<23<13A3<BB=343<2/<B=@343<2/<BLA:/EG3@A=@

2=1C;3<B/B7=<B6/B343<2/<BE=C:26/D30GD7@BC3=467A>@7=@@3>@3A3<B/B7=<=4 344@3G>AB37< 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B74427@31BA343<2/<BB=B63

;/B3@7/:A>@=2C132/A>/@B=463@<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A7<B67A1/A3 =@B63AB/B3;3<BA7<&/@/5@/>6

     =4B63;3<232=;>:/7<B4=@E6716/A>31747117B/B7=<E/A<=B>@=D7232&:/7<B74427@31BA

343<2/<BB=B63<3EA/@B71:3/D/7:/0:3/BBBB0::0;9                 2@=;<2 <=6:02.:1=2B>2C./@>2

.8824.?6;:> 6:12C5?98B63B@/<A1@7>B/D/7:/0:3/BBBB0::0;9 )'$('&)(               0::? 5?98

/<2343<2/<BLA23>=A7B7=<B3AB7;=<G/<223>=A7B7=<3F6707BA7<B63 )$%( $%")&,

                                                    
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 9 of 27

;/BB3@ =@B63AB/B3;3<B7<&/@/5@/>64=@E6716/A>31747117B/B7=<E/A<=B>@=D7232&:/7<B744

27@31BA343<2/<BB= https://www.axios.com/newsletters/axios-sneak-peek-570398b2-a21c-428e-a8f8-

a7d3dabeb30e.html. For the quote in Paragraph 59 for which a specific citation was not provided,

Plaintiff directs Defendant to

https://www.law.com/americanlawyer/almID/1202715316005/?slreturn=20200021150317. The

information in Paragraph 74 is based on confidential documentation that Plaintiff cannot disclose

absent a court order from the court in Ms. Ransome’s case against Jeffrey Epstein’s estate. <

/227B7=<&:/7<B7447A>@=2C17<563@3E7B6B6323>=A7B7=<B@/<A1@7>B=42@7/</'=AAB/93<7<!

    "($+ #%&!$=  1D + 

                99<0B:2;A@.;1<::B;60.A6<;@A5.A*<B0<;A2;1?23BA22?@5<D6AGH@

    1232;@2@6;56@;@D2?.;109.6:@6;56@<B;A2?09.6:6;A56@0A6<;

         $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=

B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@37<B6/B343<2/<B6/A<=BA3@D3267A/;3<232<AE3@/<2

=C<B3@1:/7;A )67A'3?C3AB7A/:A=>@3;/BC@3031/CA327A1=D3@G7<B67A1/A37A7<7BA7<4/<1G/<2

&:/7<B7447AAB7::7<B63>@=13AA=41=;>7:7<5/::=4B633D723<13B6/B@34CB3A343<2/<BAD/@7=CA

1:/7;A/<2/::35/B7=<A &:/7<B7444C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB031/CA37B1/::A4=@B63

723<B7471/B7=<=463@/BB=@<3GALE=@9>@=2C1B 

         (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A>@=2C132

B6=CA/<2A=4>/53A=42=1C;3<BA/<223>=A7B7=<B3AB7;=<GB6/B@34CB3343<2/<BLA2343<A3A/<2

1:/7;A7<67A=C<B3@1:/7;7<B67A1B7=</<2E7::AC>>:3;3<BB67A>@=2C1B7=</A<=B327<@3A>=<A3

B='3?C3AB$=  <G;=@323B/7:32723<B7471/B7=<=4A>3174712=1C;3<BA=@7<4=@;/B7=<B6/BE7::

03CA32B=@34CB3343<2/<BLA/<AE3@/<21:/7;AE7::032=<3/4B3@27A1=D3@G7A1=;>:3B32/<2

>C@AC/<BB=/<G1/A3;/</53;3<B=@23@/<2>@3B@7/:A1632C:3A3B0GB63=C@B4=@27A1:=A7<5

3F>3@BAE7B<3AA3A3F6707BA3B1 

                                                     
         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 10 of 27

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F<::B;60.A6<;@D6A5.;F<3A523<99<D6;4

    6;16C61B.9@<?A526?.AA<?;2F@.42;A@<??2=?2@2;A.A6C2@

                . 2?@5<D6AG

                / =@A26;

                0 [email protected];2.ED299

                1 .?6..?:2?
                
                2 %.?.5$.;@<:2

                3 B.;92@@6

                4 93?21<$<1?64B2G

                5 ;A5<;F64B2?<.

                6 $2/200.<F9.;

                7 %5.?<;5B?052?

                8 B962?<D;

                9 <;;62?B08

                : 699$605.?1@<;

                ; 2<?426A05299

                < &5<:.@"?6AG82?

                = 2@962)2E;2?

                > /64.69)2E;2?

                ? <5;+2642?

                @ 92;;B/6;

                A "?6;02;1?2D

                B 5B1.?.8

                C .?C6;6;@8F
                                                 
         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 11 of 27

                 D ".A?6082@@92?
                 E ;FD6A;2@@612;A636216;*<B?$B92   .16@09<@B?2@

                 F ;FD6A;2@@612;A636216;*<B?;@D2?@A<;A2??<4.A<?62@

          $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=B67A

'3?C3AB/A=D3@:G0@=/2 AE@7BB3<B67A'3?C3ABE=C:21/::4=@/<G2=1C;3<B1=<13@<7<5/<G

1=;;C<71/B7=</<G=4B63 A>317471/::G723<B747327<27D72C/:A/<2/<G/227B7=</:7<27D72C/:A

723<B747327<&:/7<B744LA<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A=@<B3@@=5/B=@G'3A>=<A3A;/G6/D36/2=</<GAC0831B

E6/BA=3D3@E63B63@@3:/B32B=B67A1/A3=@<=B &:/7<B7444C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A7<1:C27<5

7<27D72C/:AE6=/@3<=B@3:3D/<BB=&:/7<B744LA/::35/B7=<B6/B343<2/<BA3FC/::G/0CA3263@/<2

234/;3263@=@343<2/<BLA23<7/:=4B6=A3/::35/B7=<A )67A'3?C3AB7A/:A==0831B7=</0:3B=B63

3FB3<B7BA339A2=1C;3<BA>@=B31B324@=;27A1:=AC@30GB63/BB=@<3G1:73<BE=@9>@=2C1B1=;;=<

7<B3@3AB=@/<G=B63@/>>:71/0:3>@7D7:353 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744E7::AC>>:3;3<B63@>@7=@

>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(*);/BB3@/A<=B327<@3A>=<A3B='3?C3AB$=  0G>@=2C17<5

/<G<=<>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3<=<>@7D7:35321=;;C<71/B7=<A7<&:/7<B744LA>=AA3AA7=<E7B6=@/0=CB

/<G=4B63/0=D3723<B747327<27D72C/:A@35/@27<57AAC3A@3:3D/<BB=B67A/1B7=<B6/B>=AB2/B3B63>@7=@

>@=2C1B7=< 

                   99=5<A<4?.=5@<?C612<0<;A.6;6;4.;F6:.42<3*<B.;1A523<99<D6;4

    6;16C61B.9@

                 . 2?@5<D6AG
                     
                 / =@A26;

                 0 [email protected];2.ED299

                 1 699$605.?1@<;

                 2 2<?426A05299

         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 12 of 27

                 3 &5<:.@"?6AG82?

                 4 2@962)2E;2?

                 5 92;;B/6;

                 6 "?6;02;1?2D

                 7 5B1.?.8

                 8 .?C6;6;@8F

                 9 69996;A<;

                 : 9<?2

             ; &6==2?<?2
             
          $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=B67A

'3?C3AB/AA3397<57<4=@;/B7=</<22=1C;3<BAB6/B/@3<=B@3:3D/<BB=B67A/1B7=<=@23A75<32B=:3/2

B=B6327A1=D3@G=4@3:3D/<B7<4=@;/B7=< (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744

@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132/::@3:3D/<B2=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=</A>/@B=463@

>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@ 

                 99=5<A<4?.=5@.;1C612<<3*<B6;.;F<3=@A26;H@=?<=2?A62@6;09B16;4/BA

    ;<A96:6A21A<56@=?<=2?A62@6;".9:2.059<?61. 2D*<?86AF 2D2E60<.;1A52

    '%(6?46;@9.;1@

          $%"! %</227B7=<B=B633<3@/:%0831B7=<AA3B4=@B6/0=D3&:/7<B744=0831BAB=B67A

'3?C3AB/AA3397<57<4=@;/B7=</<22=1C;3<BAB6/B/@3<=B@3:3D/<BB=B67A/1B7=<=@23A75<32B=:3/2

B=B6327A1=D3@G=4@3:3D/<B7<4=@;/B7=< (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744

@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132/::@3:3D/<B2=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=</A>/@B=463@

>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@ 

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4*<B?:=9<F:2;A.AA52.?..4<9B/

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831B/<2

         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 13 of 27

E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=343<2/<BB63

@31=@2AA636/A@35/@27<563@3;>:=G;3<B/BB63#/@/"/5=:C07<1:C27<57<4=@;/B7=<A6=E7<5

B6/BB63#/@/"/5=:C0E/A=>3<4=@0CA7<3AA7<B63(>@7<5 (C;;3@=4                E63<&:/7<B7446/A

B3AB74732A63;3B/<2E/A@31@C7B320G67A:/7<3#/FE3:: 

                99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F:=9<F:2;A/F*<B3?<:.;B.?FA<

    =?2@2;A

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=

/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132/::@3:3D/<B

2=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=</A>/@B=463@>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@ 

                0<=F <3 *<B?3212?.9 @A.A2 <? 9<0.9 A.E ?2AB?;@ 3<? A52 F2.?@  A< A52

    =?2@2;AD52A52?3?<:A52';6A21%A.A2@<?.;F<A52?0<B;A?F

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=

    /<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=

    343<2/<B/A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<7< '$(*);/BB3@B63B/F@31=@2AA63

    6/2B6@=C56     &:/7<B744E7::1=<2C1B/@3/A=</0:3A3/@164=@/227B7=</:@3A>=<A7D32=1C;3<BA

    B6/B>=AB2/B3B63*)>@=2C1B7=</<2>@=2C13/<GAC162=1C;3<BAB=343<2/<B 

               99 <0B:2;A@ 0<;02?;6;4 (60A6:@$23B@2 %692;02 6;09B16;4 .;F<?4.;6G6;4

    1<0B:2;A@ 36;.;06.9 ?20<?1@ .;F 3<?:  <? <A52? @6:69.? A.E 1<0B:2;A@ .;1 .;F

    <0B:2;A@?23920A6;4;0<:2*<B?2026C213?<:A52<?4.;6G.A6<;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=

    /<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=

    343<2/<B/A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<4@=;<=<>/@BG+71B7;A'34CA3(7:3<137<B63

     '$(*);/BB3@@31=@2A@3A>=<A7D3B=B67A'3?C3AB &:/7<B744E7::1=<2C1B/@3/A=</0:3

    A3/@164=@/227B7=</:@3A>=<A7D32=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=<B6/B>=AB2/B3B63*)

         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 14 of 27

    >@=2C1B7=</<2>@=2C13/<GAC162=1C;3<BAB=343<2/<B )67A@3?C3AB6=E3D3@7A;=@3

    >@=>3@:G27@31B32B=+71B7;A'34CA3(7:3<13/<2&:/7<B7447A<=B@3>@3A3<B7<5B6/BA636/A/::

    2=1C;3<BAB6/B;/G037<B6/B<=<>/@BGLA>=AA3AA7=< 

                ;F16.?F7<B?;.9<?0.92;1.?0<;02?;6;4*<B?.0A6C6A62@3?<:A<  

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=

    /<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=

    343<2/<B/A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@>@=D7232/A>/@B

    =4&:/7<B744LA<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A/::2=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=<@3A>=<A7D3B=B67A'3?C3AB 

                99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4*<B?A?.C293?<:A<  6;09B16;4/BA;<A

    96:6A21A<.0<=F<3*<B?=.@@=<?A.;FC6@.6@@B21A<F<B.;FC6@..==960.A6<;=?2=.?21<?

    @B/:6AA21 <; F<B? /25.93 .;1 .;F A?.C29 6A6;2?.?F ?2026=A@ 9<4@ <? <A52? <0B:2;A@

    2C612;06;4F<B?&?.C291B?6;4A5.AA6:2=2?6<1

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=/<2

E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=343<2/<B/A

>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@>@=D7232/A>/@B=4&:/7<B744LA<7B7/:

7A1:=AC@3A/::2=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=<@3A>=<A7D3B=B67A'3?C3AB 

                99<0B:2;A@D560512:<;@A?.A2A5.A*<B:2A2?@5<D6AG

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@37<B6/B27A1=D3@G7A=<5=7<5 &:/7<B744@3A3@D3AB63@756BB=

AC>>:3;3<B63@@3A>=<A3/A/227B7=</:7<4=@;/B7=</<22=1C;3<BA/@327A1=D3@32 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G

>@=2C132B=343<2/<B/A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<BA>@=D7232E7B6&:/7<B744LA<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A/::

2=1C;3<BA7<63@>=AA3AA7=<@3A>=<A7D3B=B67A'3?C3AB7<1:C27<50CB<=B:7;7B32B=&:/7<B744LA

23>=A7B7=<B3AB7;=<G4@=;B63 '$(*);/BB3@ 

                                                     
         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 15 of 27

               99<0B:2;A@@5<D6;4.;F;0<:2*<B?2026C213?<:=@A26;<?.;F<356@

    .42;A@<?.@@<06.A2@3?<:A<A52=?2@2;A

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7AD/5C3/<2/;075C=CA031/CA3>AB37<LA

J/53<BA=@/AA=17/B3AK/@3<=B2347<32=@:7AB32/A>/@B=4B63'3?C3AB &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB

=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7BA339A7@@3:3D/<B7<4=@;/B7=< &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B

343<2/<B7<B3<2AB=7<1:C23/<GA3BB:3;3<BAE7B6>AB37<=@/<G=467A/53<BA=@/AA=17/B3A7<B63

2347<7B7=<=4J<1=;3 K&:/7<B7447A7<B3@>@3B7<5B67A'3?C3ABB=<=B7<1:C23AC16A3BB:3;3<B>/G;3<BA 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A033<C</0:3B=

:=1/B3/<GAC162=1C;3<BA 

               99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4A52A2?:@<3*<B?2;4.42:2;A<3.;F<3*<B?

AA<?;2F@

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/AA3397<57@@3:3D/<B/<27;;/B3@7/:7<4=@;/B7=<<=B23A75<32B=:3/2

B=B6327A1=D3@G=4@3:3D/<B7<4=@;/B7=< &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B

A339A27A1:=AC@3=47<4=@;/B7=<:3/@<324@=;2=1C;3<BA>@3>/@327</<B717>/B7=<=4:7B75/B7=<B6/B

1=<AB7BCB3A=@@34:31BA/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B/<2B6/B1=<B/7<A>@=B31B32/BB=@<3G1:73<B

1=;;C<71/B7=<A7<1:C27<5>@7D7:35327<4=@;/B7=<=@2=1C;3<BAA6/@32E7B63<B7B73AE7B6E6716

&:/7<B7446=:2A/1=;;=<7<B3@3AB 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA63C<23@AB/<2AB6/B

=73A(167::3@:3F<3@J(KE7::03>@=2C17<5/::3<5/53;3<B:3BB3@A03BE33<(/<2&:/7<B744 

&:/7<B744E7::/:A=>@=2C1363@3<5/53;3<B:3BB3@E7B6==>3@!7@9&"" )63A3/@3B63=<:G

/BB=@<3GA@3>@3A3<B7<5&:/7<B7447<B67A1B7=< &:/7<B744=0831BAB=>@=D727<5/<G/227B7=</:

7<4=@;/B7=<=<B635@=C<2A<=B32/0=D3 

                                                     
         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 16 of 27

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4<::B;60.A6<;@D6A5*<B?AA<?;2F@0<;02?;6;4

    2?@5<D6AG

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B1/::A4=@B63>@=2C1B7=<=4>@7D7:35322=1C;3<BA

7@@3:3D/<BB=B67A:7B75/B7=< &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7A=D3@0@=/2C<2C:G

0C@23<A=;3/<2<=B>@=>=@B7=</B3B=B63<332A=4B67A/1B7=< </11=@2/<13E7B6'C:30 

&:/7<B744AB/B3AB6/BA637AE7B66=:27<5/::@3A>=<A7D32=1C;3<BA=<B630/A7A=4B63=0831B7=<A

1=<B/7<3263@37</<2=0831BAB=>@=D727<5/>@7D7:353:=52C3B=B630C@23<A=;3/<26/@/AA7<5</BC@3

=4B67A'3?C3AB 

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4<::B;60.A6<;@D6A5*<B?AA<?;2F@0<;02?;6;4

    2@962)2E;2?

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B1/::A4=@B63>@=2C1B7=<=4>@7D7:35322=1C;3<BA

7@@3:3D/<BB=B67A:7B75/B7=< &:/7<B744=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7A=D3@0@=/2C<2C:G

0C@23<A=;3/<2<=B>@=>=@B7=</B3B=B63<332A=4B67A/1B7=< </11=@2/<13E7B6'C:30 

&:/7<B744AB/B3AB6/BA637AE7B66=:27<5/::@3A>=<A7D32=1C;3<BA=<B630/A7A=4B63=0831B7=<A

1=<B/7<3263@37</<2=0831BAB=>@=D727<5/>@7D7:353:=52C3B=B630C@23<A=;3/<26/@/AA7<5</BC@3

=4B67A'3?C3AB 

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F0<;3612;A6.96AF.4?22:2;A@2AA92:2;A

    .4?22:2;A<?<A52?0<;A?.0AB.9.4?22:2;A<3.;F86;1/2AD22;*<B.;1.;F<3A52

    3<99<D6;46;16C61B.9@

                  . =@A26;

                  / [email protected];2.ED299

                  0 699$605.?1@<;

                                                    
       Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 17 of 27

                1 2<?426A05299

                2 &5<:.@"?6AG82?
                
                3 2@962)2E;2?

                4 92;;B/6;

                5 "?6;02;1?2D

                6 5B1.?.8

                7 .?C6;6;@8F

                8 69996;A<;

                9 9<?2

          : &6==2?<?2
          
       $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7BA339A7@@3:3D/<B7<4=@;/B7=<<=B>@=>=@B7=</B3B=

B63<332A=4B67A1/A3/<2<=B23A75<32B=:3/2B=B6327A1=D3@G=4@3:3D/<B=@/2;7AA70:37<4=@;/B7=< 

&:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B1=;>:7/<13E7B67BE=C:2@3?C7@363@B=D7=:/B3B63

B3@;A=4/<GAC161=<4723<B7/:7BGA3BB:3;3<B=@1=<B@/1BC/:/5@33;3<B 

       (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G

>@=2C132B=343<2/<B63@A3BB:3;3<B/5@33;3<BE7B6 344@3G>AB37</A>/@B=463@1=<4723<B7/:

23>=A7B7=<B3AB7;=<G7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@ &:/7<B7447A>@=6707B320GB63B3@;A=4B63

A3BB:3;3<B/5@33;3<B@3/1632E7B667A:/7<3#/FE3::7<@3A=:D7<5B63 '$(*);/BB3@

4@=;27A1:=A7<5B6/B/5@33;3<BE7B6=CB0=B6/<=@23@=4/1=C@B7</1=C@B>@=13327<5/4B3@7<1/;3@/

@3D73E0GB63=C@B/<2<=B713/<2/<=>>=@BC<7BGB=0363/@20G/::=4B63>/@B73AB=B63A3BB:3;3<B

/5@33;3<B AAC;7<5B6=A31=<27B7=<A/@3A/B7A4732&:/7<B7446/A<==0831B7=<B=>@=2C17<5B6/B

A3BB:3;3<B/5@33;3<B &:/7<B7446/A<==B63@/5@33;3<BAE7B6/<G=4B63>/@B73A:7AB327<B67A'3?C3AB 

                99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F=?2@0?6=A6<;1?B4@A.82;/F*<B3?<:A<

                                                   
         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 18 of 27

    =?2@2;A6;09B16;4A52=?2@0?6/6;41<0A<?1.A2@<3=?2@0?6=A6<;.;1A521.A2@<33B93699:2;A

    <3.;F@B05=?2@0?6=A6<;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=

    /<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=

    343<2/<B/A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@@31=@2A

    @3A>=<A7D3B=B67A'3?C3AB &:/7<B744E7::1=<2C1B/@3/A=</0:3A3/@164=@/227B7=</:@3A>=<A7D3

    2=1C;3<BAB6/B>=AB2/B3B63*)>@=2C1B7=< 

                  99?20<?1@0<;02?;6;4.;FA?2.A:2;A3<?.;F[email protected]:2;A.9<?2:<A6<;.9

    0<;16A6<;D5605*<B@<B45A<??2026C213?<:.;F2.9A5.?2"?<C612?3?<:A<=?2@2;A

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 (C0831BB=

    /<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B6=A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A/:@3/2G>@=2C132B=

    343<2/<B/A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@@31=@2A

    @3A>=<A7D3B=B67A'3?C3AB &:/7<B744E7::1=<2C1B/@3/A=</0:3A3/@164=@/227B7=</:@3A>=<A7D3

    2=1C;3<BAB6/B>=AB2/B3B63*)>@=2C1B7=< 

                   99 <0B:2;A@ D5605 ?232?2;02 A52 3<99<D6;4 6;16C61B.9@ /F ;.:2 <? <A52?

    12@0?6=A6<;

                  . 2?@5<D6AG

                  / =@A26;

                  0 [email protected];2.ED299

                  1 .?6..?:2?

                  2 %.?.5$.;@<:2

                  3 B.;92@@6

                  4 93?21<$<1?64B2G

                  5 ;A5<;F64B2?<.
                  
                                                     
       Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 19 of 27

             6 $2/200.<F9.;

             7 %5.?<;5B?052?

             8 B962?<D;

             9 <;;62?B08

             : 699$605.?1@<;

             ; 2<?426A05299

             < &5<:.@"?6AG82?

             = 2@962)2E;2?

             > /64.69)2E;2?

             ? <5;+2642?

             @ 92;;B/6;

             A "?6;02;1?2D

             B 5B1.?.8

             C .?C6;6;@8F

             D 69996;A<;

             E 9<?2

             F &6==2?<?2

             G ".A?6082@@92?

             ..;FD6A;2@@612;A636216;*<B?$B92       .16@09<@B?2@

             ..;FD6A;2@@612;A636216;*<B?;@D2?@A<;A2??<4.A<?62@

       $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7A=D3@0@=/2/<2C<2C:G0C@23<A=;37<B6/B7B

A339A7@@3:3D/<B7<4=@;/B7=<7<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3/<2B6CA3?C/::G/A/D/7:/0:3B=

343<2/<B/A7B7AB=&:/7<B744>@7D7:35327<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A>@=B31B324@=;27A1:=AC@30GB63

                                                   
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 20 of 27

/BB=@<3G1:73<B/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B1=;;=<7<B3@3AB/<2=B63@/>>:71/0:3>@7D7:353A &:/7<B744/:A=

=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7B7A2C>:71/B7D3=4/<2 =@=D3@:/>AE7B6=B63@'3?C3ABA 31/CA3

7B7AC<1:3/@E6/B7<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A27443@3<B4@=;B6/BE67167A@3?C3AB327<'3?C3AB$=A  

/<2343<2/<B7AA3397<57<B67A'3?C3AB&:/7<B744=0831BA=<B635@=C<2AB6/BB67A@3<23@AB67A

'3?C3ABD/5C3/<2/;075C=CA/<2B6CA<=BAC0831BB=@3A>=<A3 

                  99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4A52"2?@<;@A<D5<:F<B09.6:F<BD2?2@2EB.99F

    A?.3360821/F=@A26;6;09B16;4/BA;<A96:6A21A<A52B;;.:21"2?@<;@?232?2;0216;F<B?

    =92.16;4@369216;A52($0A6<;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

    4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7BA339A2=1C;3<BA>@=B31B324@=;27A1:=AC@30GB63

    /BB=@<3G1:73<B/<2/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353A=@B631=;;=<7<B3@3AB=@=B63@/>>:71/0:3

    >@7D7:353A &:/7<B7444C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7BA339A7@@3:3D/<B

    7<4=@;/B7=</<2B6/B7B7A23A75<324=@B63A=:3>C@>=A3=46/@/AA7<5/<27<B7;72/B7<5&:/7<B744

    E6=E/A/D71B7;=4A3FC/:B@/447197<5 &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B

    </;7<5A=;3AC167<27D72C/:AE=C:283=>/@27H363@>6GA71/:A/43BG0/A32=<1@3270:3B6@3/BAB=

    B63A/;3 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@343@A343<2/<BB=7<4=@;/B7=<

    >@=D7232/A>/@B=463@1=<4723<B7/:23>=A7B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@/<2B=2=1C;3<BA

    >@=2C132/A>/@B=4&:/7<B744LA<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3A 

                  99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F<::B;60.A6<;@/F*<B<?<;*<B?/25.93

    D6A5.;F:216.<BA92A

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

    4C@B63@=0831BA=<B635@=C<2AB6/BB67A'3?C3ABA339A7<4=@;/B7=</<22=1C;3<BA>@=B31B320G

    B63/BB=@<3G1:73<B/<2/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353A 
                                                       
         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 21 of 27

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A>@=D7232

    343<2/<BE7B6B67A@3?C3AB327<4=@;/B7=</A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(

    *);/BB3@ &:/7<B744E7::AC>>:3;3<B63@>@7=@>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(*)

    ;/BB3@/A<=B327<@3A>=<A3B='3?C3AB$=  0G>@=2C17<5/<G<=<>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3<=<

    >@7D7:35321=;;C<71/B7=<A7<&:/7<B744LA>=AA3AA7=<B6/B>=AB2/B3B6/B>@=2C1B7=< 

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F;0<:2?2026C21/FF<B3?<:.;F:216.<BA92A

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7BA339A7<4=@;/B7=</<22=1C;3<BA>@=B31B320GB63

/BB=@<3G1:73<B/<2/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353A 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A>@=D7232

343<2/<BE7B6B67A@3?C3AB327<4=@;/B7=</A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(

*);/BB3@ &:/7<B744E7::AC>>:3;3<B63@>@7=@>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(*);/BB3@/A

<=B327<@3A>=<A3B='3?C3AB$=  0G>@=2C17<5/<G<=<>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3<=<>@7D7:3532

1=;;C<71/B7=<A7<&:/7<B744LA>=AA3AA7=<B6/B>=AB2/B3B6/B>@=2C1B7=< 

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F.0AB.9<?=<A2;A6.9/<<8A292C6@6<;:<C62<?

    <A52?:216.12.90<;02?;6;4F<B?.9924.A6<;@./<BA/26;4@2EB.99FA?.3360821/F=@A26;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B633FB3<B7BA339A7<4=@;/B7=</<22=1C;3<BA>@=B31B320GB63

/BB=@<3G1:73<B/<2/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353A 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A>@=D7232

343<2/<BE7B6B67A@3?C3AB327<4=@;/B7=</A>/@B=4B632=1C;3<B>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(

*);/BB3@ &:/7<B744E7::AC>>:3;3<B63@>@7=@>@=2C1B7=<4@=;B63 '$(*);/BB3@/A

<=B327<@3A>=<A3B='3?C3AB$=  0G>@=2C17<5/<G<=<>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3<=<>@7D7:3532

1=;;C<71/B7=<A7<&:/7<B744LA>=AA3AA7=<B6/B>=AB2/B3B6/B>@=2C1B7=< 

         Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 22 of 27

               99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4.;F1.:.42@F<B09.6:A<5.C2@B332?21.@.

    ?2@B9A<3A5299242123.:.A6<;/F2?@5<D6AG

         $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7A>@3;/BC@3 )63=C@B6/A<=B3<B3@32/1/A3

;/</53;3<B=@>@3B@7/:=@23@A3BB7<523/2:7<3A4=@B6327A1:=AC@3=43F>3@BA/<2B633F16/<53=4

3F>3@B@3>=@BAE6716E7:::793:G7<1:C23/2/;/53A3F>3@B &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B63

3FB3<B7BAC553ABA1=<B@/@GB=B63:/E7<$3E-=@9B6/B234/;/B7=<>3@A3/A/::35327<B67A1/A3

2=3A<LB>@3AC;32/;/53A=@B6/BA>317/:2/;/53A<332B=03>:3/2/<2>@=D3< 

         (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/BA636/A>@=2C132

<C;3@=CA2=1C;3<BA/A>/@B=463@>@=2C1B7=<7<B63 '$(*);/BB3@B6/BE/A>@=D7232B=

343<2/<B/A>/@B=4&:/7<B744LA<7B7/:7A1:=AC@3AB6/BAC>>=@B63@1:/7;A4=@2/;/53A )=B633FB3<B

/227B7=</:2=1C;3<BA/@3723<B74732B63GE7::03>@=2C132 &:/7<B744/:A=/<B717>/B3A=443@7<53F>3@B

B3AB7;=<G=<B67A7AAC3/<2E7::>@=D723B6/BB3AB7;=<G/<2AC>>=@B7<52=1C;3<BA/BB63B7;3A

A>31747320GB63=C@B 

               99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4@A.A2:2;A@:.12/F*<B0<;02?;6;46;.;FD.F

    A52.9924.A6<;@0<;A.6;216;A52<:=9.6;A;@D2?<?<B;A2?09.6:

         $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7A=D3@0@=/2B=B633FB3<B7BA339A2=1C;3<BA

B6/B/@3>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3/<22=1C;3<BA>@=B31B320GB63/BB=@<3G1:73<B>@7D7:353/BB=@<3G

E=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353/<2=B63@/>>:71/0:3>@7D7:353A &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B63

3FB3<B7B7A2C>:71/B7D3=4/<2 =@=D3@:/>AE7B6=B63@'3?C3ABA 31/CA37B7AC<1:3/@E6/B

7<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A27443@3<B4@=;B6/BE67167A@3?C3AB327<'3?C3AB$=A  /<2343<2/<B

7AA3397<57<B67A'3?C3AB&:/7<B744=0831BA=<B635@=C<2AB6/BB67A@3<23@AB67A'3?C3ABD/5C3/<2

/;075C=CA/<2B6CA<=BAC0831BB=@3A>=<A3 

          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 23 of 27

                 99<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4@A.A2:2;A@:.12/F.;F;<;=.?AF0<;02?;6;4A52

    .9924.A6<;@0<;A.6;216;A52<:=9.6;A;@D2?<?<B;A2?09.6:

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB=<B635@=C<2AB6/B7B7A=D3@0@=/2B=B633FB3<B7BA339A2=1C;3<BA

B6/B/@3>C0:71:G/D/7:/0:3/<22=1C;3<BA>@=B31B320GB63/BB=@<3G1:73<B>@7D7:353/BB=@<3G

E=@9>@=2C1B>@7D7:353/<2=B63@/>>:71/0:3>@7D7:353A &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B67A'3?C3ABB=B63

3FB3<B7B7A2C>:71/B7D3=4/<2 =@=D3@:/>AE7B6=B63@'3?C3ABA 31/CA37B7AC<1:3/@E6/B

7<4=@;/B7=<B6/B7A27443@3<B4@=;B6/BE67167A@3?C3AB327<'3?C3AB$=A  /<2343<2/<B

7AA3397<57<B67A'3?C3AB&:/7<B744=0831BA=<B635@=C<2AB6/BB67A@3<23@AB67A'3?C3ABD/5C3/<2

/;075C=CA/<2B6CA<=BAC0831BB=@3A>=<A3 

                 991<0B:2;A@=?<C6121A<.;F2E=2?A6;A56@0A6<;

           $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

    4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@3 )63=C@B6/A<=BG3B3<B3@32/1/A3;/</53;3<B=@

    >@3B@7/:=@23@/<2B6323/2:7<34=@723<B74G7<5B3AB74G7<53F>3@BA7A1C@@3<B:GC<9<=E< &:/7<B744

    /:A==0831BAB=B633FB3<BB63'3?C3AB1=C:203@3/2B=1@3/B3=0:75/B7=<A0@=/23@B6/</<2

    7<1=<A7AB3<BE7B6'C:3 / =4B63323@/:'C:3A=47D7:&@=132C@3AC16/A0GAC553AB7<5

    B6/BB63@37A/<=0:75/B7=<B=>@=2C132=1C;3<BA7<1:C27<5>@=B31B32/BB=@<3GE=@9>@=2C1B

    >@=D7232B=<=<B3AB74G7<51=<AC:B7<53F>3@BA 

           (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/B7</11=@2/<13

    E7B6E6/B3D3@A1632C:37AC:B7;/B3:GA3B0GB63=C@B1=<A7AB3<BE7B6B63@3?C7@3;3<BA=4'C:3

     / /<2B=B633FB3<B<=B/:@3/2G>@=2C132&:/7<B744E7::>@=2C132=1C;3<BA@3:732C>=<0G

    63@B3AB74G7<53F>3@BA 

                 991<0B:2;A@0<;02?;6;4?2=<?A@*<B5.C2?2026C213?<:2E=2?A@

    0<;@B9A.;A@<?<A52?=?<32@@6<;.9@0<;02?;6;4.;F<3A52.9924.A6<;@09.6:@<?1232;@2@.A

          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 24 of 27

    6@@B2@6;A56@0A6<;

           $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

    4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@3 )63=C@B6/A<=BG3B3<B3@32/1/A3;/</53;3<B=@

    >@3B@7/:=@23@/<2B6323/2:7<34=@723<B74G7<5B3AB74G7<53F>3@BA7A1C@@3<B:GC<9<=E< &:/7<B744

    /:A==0831BAB=B63'3?C3AB/AD/5C3/<2/;075C=CA B7AC<1:3/@E6/B/227B7=</:2=1C;3<BA=@

    7<4=@;/B7=<343<2/<B7AA3397<503G=<2E6/B7A@3?C7@320G'C:3 / =4B63323@/:'C:3A

    =47D7: &:/7<B744/:A==0831BAB=B633FB3<BB63'3?C3AB1=C:203@3/2B=1@3/B3=0:75/B7=<A

    0@=/23@B6/</<27<1=<A7AB3<BE7B6'C:3 / =4B63323@/:'C:3A=47D7:&@=132C@3AC16/A

    0GAC553AB7<5B6/BB63@37A/<=0:75/B7=<B=>@=2C132=1C;3<BA7<1:C27<5>@=B31B32/BB=@<3G

    E=@9>@=2C1B>@=D7232B=<=<B3AB74G7<51=<AC:B7<53F>3@BA 

           (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/B7</11=@2/<13

    E7B6E6/B3D3@A1632C:37AC:B7;/B3:GA3B0GB63=C@B1=<A7AB3<BE7B6B63@3?C7@3;3<BA=4'C:3

     / /<2B=B633FB3<B<=B/:@3/2G>@=2C132&:/7<B744E7::>@=2C13B633F>3@B@3>=@BA/<2

    2=1C;3<BA@3:732C>=<0G63@B3AB74G7<53F>3@BA 

                    &520B??60B9B:C6A.2<32.052E=2?AD5<:F<B2E=20AA<0.99.AA?6.96;A56@

0A6<;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@3 )63=C@B6/A<=BG3B3<B3@32/1/A3;/</53;3<B=@

>@3B@7/:=@23@/<2B6323/2:7<34=@723<B74G7<5B3AB74G7<53F>3@BA7A1C@@3<B:GC<9<=E< 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/B7</11=@2/<13E7B6

E6/B3D3@A1632C:37AC:B7;/B3:GA3B0GB63=C@B1=<A7AB3<BE7B6B63@3?C7@3;3<BA=4'C:3

    / &:/7<B744E7::>@=2C13/1C@@71C:C;D7B/3=@A7;7:/@2=1C;3<B4=@3/163F>3@BA633F>31BA

B=1/::/BB@7/: 

                    ;F.;1.991<0B:2;A@0<;@612?21<??29621B=<;/F.;F2E=2?AD5<:F<B

                                                      
          Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1058-4 Filed 06/12/20 Page 25 of 27

    6;A2;1A<0.99.AA?6.9<3A56@0A6<;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

    4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@3 )63=C@B6/A<=BG3B3<B3@32/1/A3;/</53;3<B=@

    >@3B@7/:=@23@/<2B6323/2:7<34=@723<B74G7<5B3AB74G7<53F>3@BA7A1C@@3<B:GC<9<=E< &:/7<B744

    /:A==0831BAB=B63'3?C3AB/AD/5C3/<2/;075C=CA B7AC<1:3/@E6/B/227B7=</:2=1C;3<BA=@

    7<4=@;/B7=<343<2/<B7AA3397<503G=<2E6/B7A@3?C7@320G'C:3 / =4B63323@/:'C:3A

    =47D7:&@=132C@3 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/B7</11=@2/<13E7B6

    E6/B3D3@A1632C:37AC:B7;/B3:GA3B0GB63=C@B1=<A7AB3<BE7B6B63@3?C7@3;3<BA=4'C:3

     / /<2B=B633FB3<B<=B/:@3/2G>@=2C132&:/7<B744E7::>@=2C132=1C;3<BA@3:732C>=<0G

    63@3F>3@BA 

                  99<0B:2;A@.;1<::B;60.A6<;@F<B6;A2;1A<?29FB=<;<;,@60-

    6;A?<1B026;A<2C612;02.AA?6.9<3A56@0A6<;

          $%"! %&:/7<B7447<1=@>=@/B3AB633<3@/:%0831B7=<A/A74A3B4=@B663@3 &:/7<B744

4C@B63@=0831BAB=B67A'3?C3AB/A>@3;/BC@3 7A1=D3@G7<B67A;/BB3@7A=<5=7<5/<2B63=C@B6/A

<=BG3B3<B3@32/1/A3;/</53;3<B=@>@3B@7/:=@23@/<2B6323/2:7<34=@723<B74G7<53F6707BA7A

1C@@3<B:GC<9<=E< 

          (C0831BB=/<2E7B6=CBE/7D7<5B63A3=0831B7=<A&:/7<B744@3A>=<2AB6/B7</11=@2/<13E7B6

E6/B3D3@A1632C:37AC:B7;/B3:GA3B0GB63=C@B1=<A7AB3<BE7B6B63=0:75/B7=<A7;>=A320GB63

323@/:'C:3A=47D7:&@=132C@3/<2B63"=1/:'C:3A&:/7<B744E7::>@=D723343<2/<BE7B6/<

3F6707B:7AB/<2B=B633FB3<B<=B/:@3/2G>@=2C1321=>73A=4E6/B3D3@3F6707BA&:/7<B7447<B3<2AB=

/447@;/B7D3:G@3:GC>=</BB@7/: 

                  99<0B:2;A@.;1<::B;60.A6<;@?2026C21=B?@B.;AA<@B/=<2;.@6@@B21A<

    ;<;=.?A62@6
ℹ️ Document Details
SHA-256
ab0a63d7e513cf24ab8537869ad4ed944d42c527f5af115b6f2fe1039789d97b
Bates Number
gov.uscourts.nysd.447706.1058.4
Dataset
giuffre-maxwell
Document Type
document
Pages
27
Comments 0

Loading comments…