EFTA01199181.pdf

Palm Beach Daily News: Archives 417/11 1:35 PM Slap nr almBeachDailyNpyva;c9m Newsletter Center I Log In Renew Your SiNsrnpbnn (D sae Q web YA 10°F r Thursday. April 7. 2011 HONIE NEWS SOCIETY BUSINESS ARTS FASHION OBITUARIES OPINION LIFESTYLES SHINY SHOTS ADVERTISE CONTACT US Search for Palm Beath Day News Follow ©ShinySheel on Twitter! NEWS Classifieds Real Estate Religion I Archives Advertise Automotive f7, E-mail this page f'—‘, Print this page Most popular =L 4-iirtsuP New Search Return to results Printer Friendly About your archives purchase: Your purchase of 20 articles expires on 04/07/2011 4:22 PM. You have viewed 3 articles and have 17 articles remaining. Palm Beach Daily News (FL) JUDGE RECEIVES EPSTEIN TAPE RULING PENDING MICHELE DARGAN. Daily News Staff Writer Published: May 5. 2010 NEW YORK -- A Manhattan federal judge Tuesday took into custody a tape-recorded conversation by between veteran newspaper reporter George Rush and convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. But U.S. District Judge Lawrence M. McKenna reserved ruling on whether the record:1g will be released to Shannon Donnelly attorneys representing young women who were sexually abused by Epsteii as minors. McKenna didn't listen to the recording during the hearing. Fort Lauderdale attorney Brad Edwards and Utah attorney and law professor Paul Cassell are fighting to obtal-i the 22-minute tape on behalf of Epstein victim Jane Doe. She has filed one of a dozen pending civil cases in federal cost in West Palm Beach against Epstein. A status check is set for Thursday in those cases before U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra. Doe could have settled the lawsuit for 550.000 but is asking for 550 million in damages. Cassell said Tuesday. 'Jane Doe was repeatedly sexually assaulted over a lengthy period of time by this wealthy and powerful man: Cassell said. Epstein. 57. is currently under house arrest in his Palm Beach home after serving 13 months of an 18- month state sentence for soliciting a minor for prostitution and soliciting prostitution. Nearly two dozen young women have Bed lawsuits agal-ist the bilionaie money manager -- some already settled -- all alleging Epstein sexually abused them as minors at his El Brill° Way home. Cites reporter's protected privilege Rush. of the New York Daily News, was present in the courtroom, but did not have to testify Tuesday. Neither did Fort Lauderdale private investigator Michael Fisten. also ii the courtroom. Working on behalf of Epstein victims. Fisten discovered the existence of the tape and had a conversation with Rush about its contents. Representing Rush and the newspaper. Washington attorney Laura Handman and New York Daily News attorney Anne Carroll argued the tape should not be released under any circumstances, citing reporter's protected priviege. Rush told Epstein the conversation was "off the record' and has never published any portion of that conversation. But even if portions had been printed. the unpublished portions would still be protected. Handman said. Handman cited cases where interviews were conducted in the presence of other people and privilege was not waived. In addition. Handman argued that Rush should not have to testify in court. The ability for reporter's privilege to be protected is crucial in culling sources and gathering information for news stories. Handman said. Reporting is all about give and take between the reporter and the source: that's what reporters have to do. Handman said. "This is so critical to news gathering,• Handman said. 'Mr. Rush could find himself testifying in (many] cases just because he had the temerity to do some reporting on a very important story.' There is nothing helpful to Doe's case on the tape and 'Jane Doe is not referred to once in that tape: Handman said. Cassell argued that the tape is "critical in showing Epstein's lack of remorse: Cassell described Epstein as a pitiess sexual abuser to Jane Doe and at least 30 other minor girls. Even though Jane Doe is not referred to by name on the tape. Epstein refers to his victims as lhe girls' and makes disparaging remarks about them on the tape. Cassell said. Tape played for others Cassell said priviege does not apply because it was waived when Rush played the tape for three people and verbally divulged its contents to two others. including Fisten and Edwards. who also represents two other victims. But even if there is 'qualified priviege: Cassell says, it is outweighed by Doe's inability to obtain the information anywhere else and the jury's need to hear Epstein's own words about his lack of remorse. Since Epstein has exercised his Fifth Amendment right during questioning by victims attorneys. the jury hits:, Jril.newsbank.comin search/ we /Archrves?paction =doc&p_doci...ername=dkiesq&s_accountid=AC011104062022101226 l&supgradeable =no Page 1 of 2 EFTA01199181 Palm Beach Daily News: Archives 417/11 1:35 PM will have no other way to hear Epstein's words in his own voice. Cassell said. Deadline for discovery in the Doe case is May 31. with the trial set for July 14. mdarganglpbdailynews.com Copyright (c) 2010 Palm Beach Daily News Refinance Rates at 2.65% 5160,000 Mortgage for $659/mo. No SSN roq LendGo.ccol/Mortgage Do NOT Buy Car Insurance We blind 04A how drivers can get www.NewslareakingNews.can Man "Cheats" Credit Score He Added 126 Points To His Credit Score www.CrectitRepaefFrommome COM $79/Hr lob - '67 Openlnae Make 579/hr Working From MOM. As seen on www.workfromhorneguideinet/JOOS Ads by YdhOS By using this service you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement. Copyright 2007 Palm Beach Daily News. All rights reserved. The Palm Beach Daily News Privacy Policy I About this site I Write to us catm479" http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p action=docdp doci...ername=dkiesg6s accountid=AC011104062 0 22 1012 2 61&s upgradeable=no Page 2 of 2 EFTA01199182