📄 Extracted Text (17,893 words)
Deutsche Bank
Deutsche Bank Research:
The Equity View: FRESH MONEY IDEAS #3
January 7th, 2018
Distributed on: 07/01/2018 21:00:00 GMT
Deutsche Bank does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its
research reports. Thus, investors should be aware that the firm may have a
conflict of
interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. Investors should
consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment
decision. DISCLOSURES
AND ANALYST CERTIFICATIONS ARE LOCATED IN APPENDIX 1. MCI(P) 083/04/2017
7T2se3r00t6kwoPa
EFTA01432866
Table of Contents
II The Equity View Overview
IIConsumer
— Page 5 B&M
— Page 6 BAT
— Page 7 Bovis Homes
Page 8 Carrefour - SELL
IIFinancials
— Page 10 Aroundtown Properties
— Page 11 AXA
— Page 12 Banco Santander
— Page 13 Credit Suisse Group
Page 14 Prudential
IIHealthcare
— Page 16 AstraZeneca
— Page 17 Fresenius
Page 18 Shire
IIEnergy, Materials & Industrials
— Page 20 ABB
— Page 21 ArcelorMittal
— Page 22 BAE
— Page 23 Continental
IIEnergy, Materials & Industrials cont'dm..
— Page 24 DSM
— Page 25 Glencore
— Page 26 Kingspan
— Page 27 Linde
— Page 28 Renault
— Page 29 Royal Dutch Shell
— Page 30 RWE
IITMT
— Page 32 Eutelsat - SELL
— Page 33 Infineon
— Page 34 Informa
— Page 35 KPN
— Page 36 Sophos
— Page 37 Vodafone
IIBusiness Services, Leisure & Transport
— Page 39 Deutsche Lufthansa
— Page 40 Royal Mail - SELL
— Page 41 SGS
Page 42 Vinci
II Risk Statements
EFTA01432867
II DB Forecasts
Editors: Mark Braley, Vivek-G Midha and Mairead Smith
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
2
EFTA01432868
The Equity View — Fresh Money Ideas — Overview
IIThe Equity View Overview
IIThis is the third edition of this quarterly publication, where we present
each of our teams' strongest investment ideas over the next
twelve months.
IIBelow are our European "Fresh Money Ideas". In this report, each idea is
summarized and grouped together by sector (SELLs in RED):
— Consumer: B&M, BAT, Bovis Homes, Carrefour
— Financials: Aroundtown Properties, AXA, Banco Santander, Credit Suisse
Group, Prudential
— Healthcare: AstraZeneca, Fresenius, Shire
— Energy, Materials & Industrials: ABB, ArcelorMittal, BAE, Continental,
DSM, Glencore, Kingspan, Linde, Renault, Royal Dutch
Shell, RWE
— TMT: Eutelsat, Infineon, Informa, KPN, Sophos, Vodafone
— Business Services, Leisure & Transport: Deutsche Lufthansa, Royal Mail,
SGS, Vinci
IIOne slide per stock, valuation and catalysts plus links to the latest
research.
IIThe prior iteration (04-Oct-17) [AB Foods, BAT, Bovis Homes, B&M, H&M,
Imperial Brands, Ocado, Tesco, AXA, Credit Suisse,
Deutsche Wohnen, Prudential, AstraZeneca, Coloplast, Shire, ArcelorMiittal,
BP, Centrica, Covestro, GKN, HeidelbergCement, Linde,
Renault, Rio Tinto, RWE, AccorHotels, ADP, Cineworld, Deutsche Post, IAG,
Aixtron, Informa, Micro Focus, Telefonica, Telia, TF1] saw
an average price gain to 04-Jan-18 of 4.2%, vs SXXP at 0.9% (Past
performance is not a guarantee of future performance; This data
does not include transaction costs; more information is available upon
request)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
3
EFTA01432869
Consumer
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
4
EFTA01432870
> Consumer
1 B&M — Warwick Okines, BUY, close 413p, 450p tgt, 9% upside
IIOur preference is for value retailers. The UK macro environment looks
similar to the austerity years of 2011/12. Both in groceries and in our
apparel consumer survey we can see evidence of a shift to value.
IIB&M is a price leader, with a robust 15-20% price gap to Tesco and Asda.
IIValue retailers also offer structural growth opportunities. Multi-price
discounters grew at a sales CAGR of 12% in 2006-16, illustrating their
ability to progressively gain market share.
IIB&M has ambitious store expansion plans with a UK target of 950 overall
vs. existing 552 as of Sep-17, implying 40-50 openings p.a. over nine years.
IIWe see attractive long-term growth opportunities:
— Ja Woll — a German discount retailer: we forecast a sales CAGR of
13% to 2020E.
— Heron Foods (a discounted convenience grocery retailer, purchased in
Aug-17), from expanding its existing base of 257 stores. It would also
make selling a greater range of non-ambient food products at B&M
economically attractive.
II
in
A strong balance sheet provides return optionality. At only 1.6x leverage
Mar-18 we see potential for a 15p special dividend which would imply a
5.5% dividend yield.
IIB&M trades on a CY18E P/E of 19.6x. This is only a 1.3x PEG. The
valuation does not reflect B&M's growth trajectory.
IICatalysts: Q3 results on 12-Jan.
Related DB Research:
B&M: Heron is flying (Okines)
European Non-Food Retail: Christmas turkeys and crackers (Okines)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
The price gap vs. Tesco and Asda is widening — B&M is a price leader
10%
-30%
-25%
-20%
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
Apr 14 Aug 14 Dec 14 Apr 15 Aug 15 Dec 15 Apr 16 Aug 16 Dec 16 Apr 17 Aug 17
vs Asda
vs Poundland
Source: Deutsche Bank (last data point: 10 November 17), company websites
Q2 LFL better than 01, despite Easter effect in 01
EFTA01432871
-1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
7%
8%
9%
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates, company data
5
vs Tesco
EFTA01432872
> Consumer
2 BAT — Gerry Gallagher, BUY, close 4914p, 6000p tgt, 22% upside
IIBAT offers 50% TSR over the next two years, only 15ppts of which is from
an EV re-rating.
IIIts broad offering in next generation products (NGP), both in heat-notburn
and vaping, puts BAT at a competitive advantage could fuel group
organic growth of c5% organic growth FY18 and c6% FY19.
IIBAT is one of the fastest growing large cap European staples yet it
trades at a discount to the European sector and its international peers.
0%
IIKey drivers:
— Strong organic EBITDA growth and debt pay down (c28ppts).
EBITDA growth could fuel 10% pa EPS growth, while debt pay-down
further shifts the EV to equity.
— Attractive dividend (c7ppts upside over next two years).
— Re-rating to 13.1x 18E EV/EBITDA (c15ppts upside) and still at a
discount to staples and international peers. Concerns regarding
potential plans by the FDA to reduce cigarettes' nicotine content
(announced in July 2017) have brought the multiple down to 12.4x.
— The FDA regulatory process takes many years. By its conclusion, NGPs
may already be well-established.
IICatalysts: US tax reform (could add 5-8% to EPS); FY17 results end Feb;
FDA comments through 2018
Related DB Research:
What's going on (Gallagher)
You can't have your cake and eat it (Gallagher)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
10%
EBITDA (operational) growth
Assoc. and mins.
Incremental EPS at higher P/E multiple
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates; assumes 10% EPS growth
Operational drivers are key— we see substantial EBITDA growth to come
10
12
14
16
0
2
4
6
8
FY17
FY18
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates; assumes 10% EPS growth
6
EFTA01432873
FY19
FY20
EBITDA (GBPbn) (LHS)
Growth (RHS)
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
20%
We see potential for 50% TSR over the next two years
Operational drivers: 27.8%
EV/EBITDA remains at 12.3x
21.5%
5.0%
1.3%
30%
Debt paydown
P/E expansion ex operational drivers
DPS
Re-rating: 14.8%
12.0%
2.9%
7.4%
40%
50%
EFTA01432874
> Consumer
3 Bovis Homes — Glynis Johnson, BUY, close 1185p, 1368p tgt, 15% upside
IIManagement's targets for 2020 are credible (EBIT margins >18% and
ROCE >25%) and provide scope for upside. We see scope for expansion
from the following sources:
— Land bank intake margin is 26.4%, above the gross margin target of
23.5%
— Contingency costs assumed in the current land bank and all new land
intake should edge lower. These have increased from 2.5% to 4% of
build cost, but the CEO has guided that these should fall.
— We have not included any benefits from new housetypes from 2018.
This could help bring cost savings and economies of scale.
— Admin costs are targeted to be below 5% of sales. They are at the top
of the peer group at present and so this target implies substantial cost
savings, but we believe volume improvements could help too.
II>9% dividend yield from special cash return of £180m over three years.
IIPotential for higher dividends if Bovis constrains its land buying plans.
Reducing land buying by half would increase cash available by £75m. The
CEO is incentivised to pay out more than £180m in his LTIP.
IIOrganic cash flow can support the dividend post 2020. The cash
generation potential is impressive, with a 2018E FCF yield of 18.0%.
IIStock is still cheap at 1.2x 2018E P/TNAV, despite 30% rise in last six
months.
IICatalysts: FY trading update on 12th January, FY results on 1st March.
Related DB Research:
Bovis: Benefits of strategy becoming evident (Johnson)
UK Housebuilders: 2018 Outlook — Better for longer (Johnson)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Bovis has the best yield in the sector, and one of the best in the market
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3%
Source: Deutsche Bank
McCarthy
Beltway
Berkeley
Persimmon
Red row
Crest
Barratt
Taylor
Bovis
EFTA01432875
4%
5%
6%
7%
Dividend yield
We see margin upside from the land bank, with land trailing house prices
100
110
120
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Halifax HPI
Greenfield land
8%
9%
10%
Source: Deutsche Bank, Halifax. Land: Savills UK resi land dev index.
Rebased: Dec 2007 = 100
7
Dividend cover by FCF (x)
Mar-97
Nov-97
Jul-98
Mar-99
Nov-99
Jul-00
Mar-01
Nov-01
Jul-02
Mar-03
Nov-03
Jul-04
Mar-05
Nov-05
Jul-06
Mar-07
Nov-07
Jul-08
Mar-09
Nov-09
Jul-10
Mar-11
Nov-11
Jul-12
Mar-13
EFTA01432876
Nov-13
Jul-14
Mar-15
Nov-15
Jul-16
Mar-17
EFTA01432877
> Consumer
4 Carrefour — Maxime Mallet, SELL, close €18.3, €15 tgt, 18% downside
IIWe believe 2018 consensus is at risk. We are 13% below consensus 18E
EPS (and 15% below 19E consensus).
IICarrefour needs to invest given competitive pressures in France.
Hypers (52% of French sales) suffers from a 5% price gap vs. Leclerc and
underexposure to online grocery (with only 8% market share).
IINovember's Kantar data showed a market share loss of 60bps to 20.5%.
— This is not confined to Hypers (40bps share loss); Supers also lost
30bps of market share.
IIRecent price and promotional investments have not delivered better
customer perceptions. Price perceptions are broadly flat YoY for both
Supers and Hypers. Therefore, more will be needed.
IICarrefour's market position is already weak. French EBIT margin is at a
historical low of 2.0% in 2017E.
IIClosing the gap to peers would be expensive. Eliminating it would cost
the entirety of French EBIT.
IIThe strategic plan in January is likely to be underwhelming. The first
measures taken by the new management do not address the main issues
and it will be costly and take time to fix the group's positioning
IICash flow generation is structurally weak. The meagre 2.6% FCF yield
is linked to thin margins in a tough competitive environment and a high tax
rate of 35%.
IICarrefour still trades at a 11% premium to peers at 16x 18E EPS.
IICatalysts: strategic plan on January 23rd.
Related DB Research:
French Food Retail: A stronger November and a weaker Carrefour (Mallet)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
French profitability is falling
33,000
33,500
34,000
34,500
35,000
35,500
36,000
36,500
Sales (in €m, LHS)
EBIT margin (RHS)
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
EFTA01432878
3.0%
3.5%
4.0%
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017E 2018E
Source: Company reports, Deutsche Bank estimates
Narrowing the gap vs. Leclerc would be costly
1,000
1,200
200
400
600
800
-45
-200
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
EBIT (LHS)
EBIT margin (RHS)
852
672
493
313
134
1,031
-1%
0%
1%
1%
2%
2%
3%
3%
4%
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates (Carrefour Hypers vs. Leclerc on horizontal;
France EBIT on LHS; France EBIT margin on RHS)
8
EFTA01432879
Financials
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
9
EFTA01432880
> Financials
5 Aroundtown Properties — Markus Scheufler, BUY, close €6.5, €7.50 tgt, 15%
upside
IIWe like Aroundtown as a play on a stronger German economy. Its portfolio
is primarily based in German cities (88% of portfolio) and is mostly geared
towards commercial property (76% of assets).
IIKey driver #1: Acquisitions keep beating expectations. Aroundtown has
closed €3bn of acquisitions YTD at a 6.3% yield.
IIWe believe that Aroundtown should be able to continue making acquisitions
below replacement costs for the next two to three years.
IIRefinancing could drive cash flow upside.
— Re-gearing the portfolio from 35% LTV at a low 1.5% marginal cost of debt
would lock in a 500bps spread
IIKey driver #2: strong rental growth of >5% pa. We forecast a 23% FF0
CAGR to 2020E. This in turn is driven by:
— Closing the 20% gap to market rents for c90% of the portfolio.
Aroundtown's strategy is to acquire undermanaged assets, refurbish
them and realise the market upside;
— LFL rental growth of 4%;
— A fall in vacancy rates to c5% from c7%
IIKey driver #3: we expect a 12% NAV growth to 2020E, driven not just by
rental growth but also by:
— Revaluation — H1 revaluation to 5.5% yield was a positive surprise
— Better portfolio quality and thus yield compression
IIAroundtown currently trades on a discount to book value at 0.9x 2018E
IIThe next catalyst is potential inclusion in the MDAX in March
Related DB Research: 3017 results: Strong growth continues: BUY (Scheufler)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Acquisition volume continues to surprise to the upside
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
500
0
2015
Source: Company data, Deutsche Bank estimates
20% upside to market rents drives LFL rental growth
100 %
88%
10
20
EFTA01432881
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
0
Below market rent
Source: Company data, Deutsche Bank
10
At market rent
2016
2017 YTD
Acquisition volume (in EURm)
Acquisition yield (%, RHS)
4
4.5
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
12%
EFTA01432882
> Financials
6 AXA — Oliver Steel, BUY, close €25.20, €28.50 tgt, 13% upside
IIAXA is geared to rising bond yields, especially in the US, and the DB house
view sees upside to bond yields from better macro.
— The downside in any case is modest: US 10 year would need to fall to
1.5% before further reserving fears could be valid.
IIThe solvency ratio is robust at 200%.
IIWe see re-rating potential as M&A plans are executed. This cannot be risk
free, but the scale of the plans is modest in the context of the group
(planned disposals account for 13% of group earnings); yet the shares now
trade 15% below the sector.
IIWe see earnings upgrade potential on delivery of the five-year plan.
— Management has recently reiterated its confidence in the group target
of 5% pa EPS growth in 2015-2020 (despite FX headwinds). This
implies c.7% pa growth over the course of 2018e-2020e.
IIOur forecasts are in line with management's 5% p.a. base case, but are
still
conservative. For instance, we do not incorporate any revenue benefit from
the 'simplify to accelerate' programme (focusing on only 16 principal
countries, reducing management layers).
IIThe simplification programme should deliver the equivalent of €0.3bn in
cost
savings within two years (c5% of 2016 net income).
IIIn summary, AXA is far too cheap at a 15% discount to the sector — with
the potential to re-rate in 2018. It currently trades on 9.5x 2019E, vs
conglomerate peers at 11.7x and sector at 11.Ox
IICatalysts: planned M&A during 2018; FY and 1H results.
Related DB Research:
AXA: A confident investor day update (Steel)
European Insurers: 2018 - Safety and Optionality (Steel)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Potential for significant EPS acceleration — and on delivery, re-rating
10%
12%
-8%
-6%
-4%
-2%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
2016
EFTA01432883
Bd ylds
Growth
Source: Company data, Deutsche Bank estimates
11
2017e
Efficiency
Equ mkts & FX
2018e
2019e
Tech margin
Total
M&A
2020e
Potential EPS growth based on AXA targets
EFTA01432884
> Financials
7 Banco Santander — Ignacio Ulargui, BUY, close €5.6, €6.6 tgt, 17% upside
IISantander is a very large cap stock (market cap > €90bn) with significant
earnings momentum and an attractive valuation.
IIWe expect high-single-digit growth in Brazil over the next two years
driven by the economic recovery.
— NII should rise at a c4% CAGR for 18-19E driven by stronger loan
growth (we expect 10%/12% in 18E/19E). Santander has been the most
active in increasing lending, being the only Brazilian bank posting both
YoY and QoQ growth.
— The economic recovery should help reduce cost of risk and hence
provisions. We forecast a 59bps fall in the cost of risk through to 2019.
IICosts and provisions should deliver profit growth in Spain. Popular's
contribution could be bigger than expected driven by revenues and lower
provisions (the company expects the acquisition of Popular to deliver €550m
of synergies), and NPAs should fall over time to non-material levels.
IIThe USA has revenue and cost tailwinds to come, starting 1H18.
IIThe UK is becoming less of a drag. Competition necessitates
management's margin caution, but the outlook on costs of risk and
operations is more positive.
IIClient loyalty focus should bring fee income outperformance. Realising
the potential from the 131m customer base should deliver a 7% fee income
CAGR in 2018-19E
IISantander has a P/B of only 0.9x for an estimated 11.4% 18E RoTE.
IICatalysts — UK & Brazil newsflow and quarterly results
Related DB Research:
Reaffirming targets. Buy reiterated (Ulargui)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Santander Brasil is achieving market-leading loan growth
10%
6.4%
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
4.2%
-1.0%
-6.8%
306
Santander Brazil
406
Bradesco
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates and company data
EFTA01432885
Spanish NPAs over loans have been materially reduced
10%
12%
14%
16%
18%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
Pre Blackstone deal
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates, company data
12
Post Blackstone deal
49% stake in
Blackstone's
vehicle
1017
Itau
2Q17
3Q17
Banco do Brazil
7.6%
EFTA01432886
> Financials
8 Credit Suisse — Kinner Lakhani, BUY, close CHF17.8, CHF21 tgt, 18% upside
IICS has superior Wealth Management operating momentum of 13%
CAGR PBT over the next 3 years supported by its Relationship Manager
investments, One Bank strategy and strong cost control
IIIt has strong cost control with a targeted 2018 cost base of <CHF17bn,
c20% down on 2015, with recent new guidance of CHF16.5-17bn over
2019-20.
IIAttractive capital return based on c50% payout ratio through 2019 and
2020 — primarily through share buybacks and special dividends — implying a
'yield' of over 5-6%
IIThere is upside potential to our forecasts. This comes from three
sources: (i) Lower funding costs of CHF1.1bn by 2019E (Dec-17 Investor
Day), improving by CHF0.5bn vs. Dec-16 Investor Day (ii) NII benefit from
forward rate curves of CHF0.45bn over 2018-20; and (iii) Lower Group tax
rate of c23%, from c28%, in the event of US tax reform.
— Lower tax alone could drive an earnings upgrade of c7% while better NII
trends could drive a c10% upgrade. This could increase our fair value
of the stock from CHF21 to CHF24.
IICS trades on only clOx adj. 19E P/E and 1.0x 19E P/TB, while offering a
10.5% 19E RoTE.
IICatalysts: US tax reform passage, further delivery towards targets
Related DB Research:
Credit Suisse: From momentum to capital return (Lakhani)
European Banks Strategy: Road to Recovery — Intrinsic Value (Lakhani)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
35
40
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
Quarterly adjusted cost trends show strong execution
2015
CHFbn
5.2
4.8
4.6
5.3
4.9
4.5
4.9
4.8
4.4
4.9
-4.5
EFTA01432887
2016
2017
5 8
10
20
3Q
40
Source: Deutsche Bank ests, company data. Note: based on adj total operating
expenses at constant FX rates, 4017 is a company est
10%
12%
14%
16%
18%
3017-2020E CETI glide path: attractive capital return to come
3.3%
(0.4%)
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
13.2%
12.8%
(1.7%)
=4.5%/6.0%
dividend
yield in
19E/20E
(2.5%)
11.9%
3017 CET1
capital ratio
Net change,
4Q17-2018E
2018E CET1
captial ratio
Earnings,
Dividends,
2019-2020E 2019-2020E
Regulation
and others,
2019-2020E
2020E CET1
capital ratio
Source: Deutsche Bank ests, company data. Note: based on adj total operating
expenses at constant FX rates, 4017 is a company est
13
EFTA01432888
> Financials
9 Prudential — Oliver Steel, close 1898p, 2050p tgt, 8% upside
IIValuation is simply too low at just 5% premium to the wider sector (PE
11.5x 2019e vs broad sector at 10.8x), despite a superior growth rate
(EPS CAGR to 2020 at 10%).
IILong-term growth in Asia is the heart of the investment case: insurance
spend in Asia is only 2.5% of GDP vs 7.5% in the UK, and mutual fund FuM
only 12% of GDP vs Europe at 75%. We forecast 13-14% pa growth in Asia.
IIPru holds top 3 positions in 9 of its 11 Asian markets. Asia is 36% of IFRS
profits and 66% of new business profit.
IIIn the US (39% of profits), Pru is no. 1 in the variable annuity market by
sales, with these accounting for only 12% of US retirement AuM.
Consensus growth expectations are low following the DOL changes, with
scope for positive surprise. Tax reform could also deliver further upside.
IIThe UK — 15% of IFRS earnings — is less exciting, but offers potential
capital release and 5% re-rating from its annuity and other closed books.
IIShort-term headwinds have turned in Pru's favour: Asia sales are more
robust (double-digit growth in most countries, thus less reliant on mainland
Chinese purchases in HK); fund management inflows are positive again; US
sales are bottoming out. A partial offset is £ recovery (80% of earnings are
non-GBP).
IICapital position offers optionality: group Solvency II capital ratio end
2016 at 201%, growing at 5pts p.a., with ability to remit up from each major
unit.
IICatalysts: sale of UK annuity book, US tax changes
Related DB Research:
Global Asset Managers: At a critical juncture (Lakhani & Steel)
European Insurers: 2018 - Safety and Optionality (Steel)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Asian sales growth, the key group driver, is broadening out again
HK
Non-HK
20%
40%
60%
80%
-20%
0%
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates, Company data
Total Asia VNB growth
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
EFTA01432889
10%
15%
20%
25%
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates, DataStream consensus and share price
14
Upside to target based on weighted peer sum of the parts
Implied Upside
Typical range since 2012
1Q10
2Q10
3Q10
4Q10
1Q11
2Q11
3Q11
4Q11
1Q12
2Q12
3Q12
4Q12
1Q13
2Q13
3Q13
4Q13
1Q14
2Q14
3Q14
4Q14
1Q15
2Q15
3Q15
4Q15
1Q16
2Q16
3Q16
4Q16
1Q17
2Q17
EFTA01432890
Healthcare
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
15
EFTA01432891
> Healthcare
10 AstraZeneca — Richard Parkes, BUY, close 5171p, 5700p tgt, 10% upside
II2018 is a likely turning point for margin and EPS momentum. We
believe EPS should grow at a c12% EPS CAGR to 2022 as it emerges from
its patent cliff and margins grow.
IIBest-in-class pipeline. Exceptional data on new oncology portfolio puts AZ
in a strong position despite MYSTIC failure.
— Expectations for the overall survival readout of MYSTIC in 1H18 are
low, so this is close to a free option in our view. A positive would deliver
>10% upside.
— The new portfolio, plus other growth products, should add >$2bn in
incremental sales in 18E.
IISubstantial margin leverage momentum improvement. Several new
launches leverage existing infrastructure and thus will have very high
margins
— We expect flat EPS in 2018, but substantial growth thereafter. The
equity story should shift to one of delivering or beating on revenue and
earnings expectations.
IIThe best-in-class growth justifies a larger premium than at present. The
shares trade on 17x 18E P/E vs. 16x for peers.
IIMultiple catalysts from pipeline. Data on existing drugs Imfinzi and
Lymparza in 1Q18, plus readouts on two potential blockbusters in
roxadustat (anemia in chronic kidney disease) and anifrolumab (lupus) in
the next 12 months.
Related DB Research:
Lynparza survey supports market leadership in potential >$7bn class; Buy
(Parkes)
Pharma: 2018 Outlook: Fundamentals solid but fewer debates than in prior
years (Parkes)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Bull/bear case: limited downside, substantial upside potential
1500p
2500p
3500p
4500p
5500p
6500p
7500p
Current
share price
1083p
4389p
228p
5700p
513p
285p
EFTA01432892
513p
7011p
Bear Pipeline -ve Mystic -ve Base
Source: Deutsche Bank
Tagrisso
Bull
Mystic +ve Pipeline
success
Substantial EPS acceleration from 2018 driven by top-line growth
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
5,000
0
2015A
2016A
Source: Deutsche Bank, company data
16
2017E
2018E
2019E
2020E
2021E
2022E
Total revenues ($m)
Core EPS ($)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Bull
EFTA01432893
> Healthcare
11 Fresenius — Gunnar Romer, BUY, close €65.4, €83 tgt, 27% upside
IIStrong outlook — we expect defensive low-teens EPS growth to 2020,
given sound end market dynamics, market leadership positions, and a
strong management team.
IIWeak sentiment means the negatives are priced in. The shares have
been weak recently on concerns over IV generics pricing and the poor
performance of Akorn.
— We expect consensus estimates to trough on 4Q17 results and to
drive further buying of the shares.
— IV generics price pressure is not outside of expectation to reassure
— 'Lowering the bar' on Akorn should remove a key overhang.
II4Q17 results should be strong. We expect adj. NI up 22% CER, helped
by a full contribution from Qironsalud and soft comps at Kabi.
IIValuation is undemanding at 20x 18E P/E, in line with historical 12m
forward range of 18-22x P/E
II A number of positive catalysts to come.
— New product launches at Kabi should surprise to the upside.
— Qironsalud integration is progressing smoothly
— Helios Capital Markets Day should be reassuring.
Related DB Research:
European MedTech & Services: 2018E Outlook: Significant Outperformance (Wang)
Source: Factset, Deutsche Bank
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
17
Fresenius has de-rated over 2017 closer to its historical average...
10
15
20
25
30
5
Jan-98 Jan-00 Jan-02 Jan-04 Jan-06 Jan-08 Jan-10 Jan-12 Jan-14 Jan-16
Source: Factset
... driving underperformance relative to the market (here, STOXX 600)
20
40
60
80
-60
-40
—20
0
66
54
36
EFTA01432894
22 25
6
-9
-24
-43
11 10
-8
-20
25
7 11 12
14
46
Fresenius lyr fwd PE
Average since 1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
EFTA01432895
> Healthcare
12 Shire — Richard Parkes, BUY, close 3875p, 5000p tgt, 29% upside
IIWe expect new long-term targets to help rebuild investor
confidence. We expect these targets to reassure that Shire can continue to
grow despite headwinds to haemophilia. Between this, execution
on deleveraging and completion of the Neuroscience Review (at end-17),
the share price should recover.
IISynergies and deleveraging should offset headwinds in '18, delivering
revenue growth. Growth of Immunology and from recent launches should
drive top-line growth.
IIMore long-term safety data needed before Shire could be displaced in
haemophilia (24% of sales). Hemlibra is a competitive threat to Shire, but a
majority of patients will need more evidence on safety given safety issues
observed in its inhibitors trials.
IIExpert feedback suggests Shire will emerge as dominant in HAE with
Lanadelumab (launch expected in 2H18).
IIShares are far too cheap at just 8x 19E PE and 9x EV/EBITDA. Shire is
the cheapest stock in our coverage after '17 underperformance, driven by
earnings downgrades.
IIConsensus has overlooked new pipeline opportunities. We see positive
surprise potential on these programmes, particularly if clinical data
supports
attractive pricing for SHP621 (est. 150k patients in the US alone, many of
whom have few effective treatments).
Related DB Research:
Shire: Headline HAVEN 3 data incrementally better than anticipated (Parkes)
Pharma: 2018 Outlook: Fundamentals solid but fewer debates than in prior
years (Parkes)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Bull/bear case: blue sky yields almost 45% upside
1500p
2000p
2500p
3000p
3500p
4000p
4500p
5000p
5500p
6000p
Current
share price
3112p
594p
817p
4523p
EFTA01432896
258p
216p
4997p
380p
5377p
Source: Deutsche Bank
Shares are now very cheap on lyr PE vs. EU Pharma
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
Jan 10
Source: Deutsche Bank
18
Dec 11
Shire lyr fwd PE rel to EU Pharma
Rel to EU Pharma 4yr Ave
+1 s.d.
-1 s.d.
Dec 13
Dec 15
Dec 17
PE rel to sector (x), lY fwd
EFTA01432897
Energy, Materials and Industrials
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
19
EFTA01432898
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
13 ABB — Gael de Bray, BUY, close CHF26.7, CHF29 tgt, 9% upside
IIABB has a late cycle profile (60% of sales - skewed towards
process/hybrid industries). We expect the shares to track orders, rather than
earnings in 2018.
IIWe foresee a rebound in orders from a trough in 2017. 2017 was a
transition year, with large orders falling to a ten-year low. Improved macro,
favourable financing conditions and ageing assets should provide a
supportive environment.
IIIP growth has historically led capex growth by around one year, and
from unsustainably low levels we believe a rebound in heavy and process
industries is on the way. Previously-delayed, large projects in grid
connections are also expected to move forward in the US and Europe over
the next few years
IIAcquisitions should deliver benefits. The costs of the expensive
acquisitions of B&R and GE IS are now sunk, whereas the benefits of #2
positions in automation (behind Siemens) and electrification (behind
Schneider) should be substantial.
IIABB has market-leading offerings in areas such as robotics, EV fast
chargers, energy storage and smart grid offerings. R&D expenses have
increased by c.100bps since 2008, reinforcing the group's innovation
capabilities.
IIWe expect re-rating relative to the sector. Given favourable conditions,
ABB's former premium to the market should return after a hiatus since 2009.
ABB currently trades on 18.4x 18E P/E.
IICatalysts: 4Q17 results on 08-Feb
Related DB Research:
ABB: Better late (cycle) than never (de Bray)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
ABB's large orders ($m) hit a low in 2017 — we expect improvement
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
7,000
8,000
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017e 2018e
Source: Deutsche Bank, ABB
ABB 12m fwd P/E relative to sector average — premium has eroded postcrisis
06
0.7
0.8
EFTA01432899
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
Nov-07
Nov-08 Nov-09 Nov-10 Nov-11 Nov-12 Nov-13 Nov-14 Nov-15 Nov-16 Nov
Source: Factset
20
10-year average
EFTA01432900
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
14 ArcelorMittal — Bastian Synagowitz, BUY, close €28.7, €33 tgt, 15% upside
M Despite having performed well recently, we believe the stock is still
priced
for a "cautious" $7bn EBITDA scenario. This appears too bearish as spot
conditions remain strong and three structural changes have removed
part of the downside risk:
IIFirstly, Europe is seeing the strongest consolidation dynamic since the
creation of ArcelorMittal itself.
IISecond, trade policy continues to become stricter in MT's US and
European core markets.
IIThird, China is aiming to cut capacity 10-20%. Our checks (and rising
margins in China) support the view this is for real.
IIAlthough we model a steel price correction from spot (suggests $10bn
EBITDA), we believe the stock comes with three free options beyond our
base case scenario (stronger developed market margins, Brazilian recovery,
commodity price holding up better) which means it could almost double
in a blue sky.
IIMT should end 2017 with net debt of c.$10bn, vs Q4 run rate EBITDA of
$8bn. Its strong 2018 FCF yield of 8-11% suggest high potential for
attractive cash returns mid-term: $2.9bn of FCF, and just $0.3bn of divis in
our model.
II Valuation: MT trades at 5.0x 2018E EV/EBITDA, 14% discount to peers
II
in
Catalysts: trade policy, steel margins holding up better, further rebound
iron ore. Q4 results 9-Feb.
Related DB Research:
Notes from the road: US NDR (Synagowitz)
Another round of upgrades and still room to go — BUY, PT to USD38
(Synagowitz)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Expectations are sensible but the shares do not reflect the ongoing earnings
recovery yet
100
120
20
40
60
80
0
Source: Datastream
Sales by end-market (2016)
Mining, Chemical & Water 1%
Packaging 4%
EFTA01432901
Other steel 11%
Transformation 12%
Construction 18%
Auto 20%
Source: Deutsche Bank
21
Other sales 8%
AM - share price performance (EUR) (LHS)
1 yr rolling EBITDA consensus (USDm) (RHS)
2 yr rolling EBITDA consensus (USDm) (RHS)
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
Dec/09 Dec/10 Dec/11 Dec/12 Dec/13 Dec/14 Dec/15 Dec/16 Dec/17
Distribution 26%
EFTA01432902
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
15 BAE Systems — Jaime Rowbotham, BUY, close 574p, 730p tgt, 27% upside
IIWe see scope for 63% TSR to 2020. With FCF forecast at £1.35bn in 2020,
if the stock were to trade on a 5% yield then those buying now would make
18% TSR per year. Thus now is an attractive entry point into a multi-year
defence spending up-cycle.
IIFlat earnings are masking a compelling growth story. We forecast EBIT
growth at 5% at the company level.
IIUS strength (9% EBIT CAGR to 2020) should come from growth in
Combat Vehicles & Ship Repair and Electronic Systems, and a profit
recovery at Applied Intelligence in Cyber.
IIIt should be possible to offset declining Typhoon profit contribution in
Air. The key drivers of this are Missiles (MBDA, in which BAE has a 37.5%
stake, is growing at a 12% pa EBIT CAGR), Aftermarket and the stake in
the F-35. There is upside potential to this from potential new Typhoon
orders, such as from Saudi Arabia.
IIMaritime profitability is well-underpinned under this UK government,
though there is risk from a change in government.
IICash conversion is set to improve from here on lower outflows on
working capital, provisions (as most are now non-operational) and pensions
(post the triennial review).
IIBAE trades on a discount to EU and US peers at c13.5x 19E P/E and
c9x 19E EV/EBIT, versus 14.5x and 10.5x for EU peers, and 19x and 14x
for US peers.
IICatalysts: conversion of contract opportunities
Related DB Research:
BAE: Cashing in: >60% 3-year TSR potential (Rowbotham)
Global Aerospace and Defence: Civil selective; Defence more effective
(Kerner)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
PER premium/discount vs US defence
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates
22
EV/EBIT premium/discount vs US def
£1.35bn FCF by 2020, driven by EBIT growth and better cash conversion
1000
1200
1400
1600
200
400
600
800
598
EFTA01432903
115
110
90
282
127
840
93
(25)
(40)
1350
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates
BAE trades on a c30% discount relative to its US peers
-80%
-60%
-40%
-20%
0%
20%
40%
60%
EFTA01432904
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
16 Continental — Tim Rokossa, BUY, close €232.3, €250 tgt, 8% upside
II1) Automotive outperformance is at an inflection point. Continental has
taken Valeo's mantle as the fastest-growing European supplier. Automotive
organic growth was 9% in 03 (700bps above global production and 250bps
above Valeo).
II2) Continental is the best play on the autos 'mega trends.' Continental
is a leader in all of:
— Autonomous driving — indeed, the world's largest player. This segment
grew 41% yoy in 9M17. This is not limited to Chassis & Safety but also
includes software, consolidated in the Interior division.
— Electrification. According to Continental, its content per car could be up
to 3x higher for a full EV compared to a standard gasoline engine.
— Digitalisation
IIThe mix shift away from diesel helped turbochargers grow >50% in Q3.
II3) Rubber should accelerate further. The margin was a slight beat in Q3.
With a negative raw mat impact abating in coming quarters, and given our
expectation that price increases (+2% in Q3) will prove sticky, we expect
earnings momentum to accelerate.
II4) Valuation: Continental has €20 upside just to reach a valuation in line
with peers (current 18E P/E is only 11.2x), despite robust growth
IICash generative (€2.4bn ex M&A this year). We see scope to increase
pay-out, given CFO guidance of no major transactions in the short term.
IICatalysts: FY results 09-Jan — talk around ADAS could offset cautious
guidance
Related DB Research:
What Conti's CFO statements mean for our view on 2018 (Rokossa)
Get ready for a good 2018 (Rokossa)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Source: Company data, HIS (* (OE since 2014, OE+RT before)
Order intake backs thesis of stronger growth ahead
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
0
5
2010
Source: Company data
23
2011
2012
EFTA01432905
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
Continental was one of the fastest growing auto suppliers in Q3
10%
12%
14%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
EFTA01432906
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
17 DSM — Virginie Boucher-Ferte, BUY, close €81.8, €100 tgt, 22% potential
upside
IIWe see Nutrition (68% of EBITDA) as a key growth driver. We forecast a
9% EBITDA 2018-20E CAGR driven by cost cutting, innovation and
leverage of its broad portfolio.
— A greater proportion of the Nutrition portfolio is in higher-value and
faster-growing ingredients and 'solutions' rather than just vitamins.
IIUp to 30% upside to 18E EBITDA forecast if vitamin price increases are
sustained.
— Prices are unlikely to revert fully: China's environmental policies are
should give structural support in the long term.
IIFull exit from Materials likely, driving portfolio shift towards becoming a
ure play in higher-value ingredients.
rIM&A should drive the next phase of development. DSM is likely to use its
strong balance sheet (0.5x 17E net debt/EBITDA) to broaden its
ingredients portfolio.
— This would unlock >€20/share of value from EPS accretion and rerating.
II
Trades on 16x 19E P/E, in line with chems but a 33% discount to
ingredients. We believe the portfolio shift should prompt re-rating.
IIOur €100 tgt implies a 20x 19E P/E — still a 15% discount to ingredients.
IICatalysts: Upside through higher value and fast growing ingredients and
"solutions". Portfolio shift optionality.
Related DB Research:
DSM: The path to E100 (and potentially more): upgrade to BUY (Boucher-Ferte)
Ingredients: 2018 Outlook: Recipe for success (Boucher-Ferte)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
DSM Nutrition organic growth now compares well to peers
10%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
7%
8%
9%
2009
2010
Source: Deutsche Bank, Company Data
1000
1500
EFTA01432907
2000
2500
3000
500
-500
0
2007
2009
Source: Deutsche Bank, Company Data
24
2011
2013
2015
2017E
2019E
Lots of firepower for accretive M&A (DBe synergies 6% of sales)
Net Debt (LHS)
2011
DSM Nutrition organic growth
Food Ingredients organic growth average
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017E
Net Deb/EBITDA (RHS)
-0.50
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
EFTA01432908
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
18 Glencore — Liam Fitzpatrick, BUY, close 391p, 430p tgt, 10% upside.
IIStrong organic growth from return of suspended capacity. Group
volume growth is c7% pa to 2020, vs. peers at 2-3%. Giving full value for
suspended capacity yields a blue-sky valuation of >15/share.
— Suspended zinc production stands at 500 Ktpa — we have
c90/320/400kt of volume growth in 2018-20 in our numbers.
— Also there is substantial suspended copper capacity. We have 8% YoY
volume growth to 2020 in our numbers.
— On copper, we are conservative given operational and country
(DRC/Zambia) risks, so the risks to our estimates are to the upside.
IIRight base metal exposure. We are structurally bullish on copper, zinc,
nickel and cobalt.
— We believe copper will remain in deficit in 2018, which should
support the copper price increases. Our forecasts are 297c in 2018E
and 315c in 2019E, putting us 10% ahead of consensus.
— Glencore's copper business is well-positioned on scale, margins and
growth.
An EV play. Glencore is a longer-term structural winner of any shift to EVs
given its strength in copper, cobalt and nickel.
IIValuation is attractive at 2018 FCF yield of 14% at spot and 11% at our
base case.
IICatalysts: Copper prices/supply disruption, consensus upgrades, delivery
against volume guidance
Related DB Research:
Glencore: Investor call — what did we learn? BUY case remains intact
(Fitzpatrick)
European Mining 2018 Outlook: Upside remains: a guide to 2018 (Fitzpatrick)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
We see the copper market moving further into deficit
(kt)
200
400
600
800
Surplus/(Deficit)
Surplus (Deficit) % of total demand
-600
-400
-200
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017e 2018e 2019e 2020e 2021e
Source: Deutsche Bank, Industry data
Substantial volume growth to 2020E in zinc (below) and copper (8% p.a.)
(kt)
1000
EFTA01432909
1100
1200
1300
1400
1500
1600
600
700
800
900
2014
2015
Source: Deutsche Bank, Industry data
25
2016
2017F
2018F
2019F
2020F
-2%
-2%
-1%
-1%
0%
1%
1%
2%
2%
3%
3%
4%
EFTA01432910
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
19 Kingspan — Priyal Mulji, BUY, close €38.5, €40 tgt, 4% upside
IIKingspan is a global insulation producer, focusing on high-performance
panels and boards.
IIWe expect robust organic growth (5% p.a. to 20E). Kingspan should
outperform its construction markets owing to its over-exposure to markets
with low penetration rates (the USA, EM and Mainland Europe) and endusers'
increasing focus on future-proofing buildings.
IIWe see c4% upside to 2020E DBe forecasts if Kingspan meets its
penetration targets.
IIWe are already c2-3% ahead of consensus post-'17 on top line and
trading profit.
IIM&A could drive c30% upside to our price target. We expect robust
FCF/sales of 5-8% in coming years.
— Levering to 2x net debt/EBITDA to spend on acquisitions would raise
our forecast 20E EPS by up to c20%.
— Management has cited M&A as a likely growth driver
IIKingspan trades at a 24% discount to high-growth cyclical stocks.
Comparing Kingspan's operational strengths (organic growth, EBITDA
progression, scale of deleveraging and predictability and earnings) and
EV/EBITDA to similar stocks such as Geberit and Halma illustrates that
Kingspan offers excellent value.
IICatalysts: FY17 results on 23-Feb
Related DB Research:
Kingspan: Insulated growth; Initiating on BUY (Mulji)
Building & Construction: 2018 Outlook: Still opportunity (Johnson)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
9
2%
3%
Source: Deutsche Bank, company data
4%
Renishaw
Geberit
Rotork
Leg rand
Polypipe
EFTA01432911
5%
2018-20E average organic growth pa, %
26
6%
7%
Givaudan
Spirax-Sarco
Assa Abloy
Kingspan
Halma
We expect a step-up in organic growth...
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
4,500
5,000
500
0
Source: Deutsche Bank, company data
m but the valuation does not reflect this
Revenue, EUR m (lhs)
% YoY organic (rhs)
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
14%
2018E EV/EBITDA, x
EFTA01432912
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
20
Linde — Tim Jones, BUY, close €186.1, €227 tgt, 22% upside.
IIKey driver #1: improving gas industry fundamentals from cost
efficiencies, investment discipline, consolidation and end-market
stabilisation. Capex to sales has fallen from c14% in 2012/13 to c12% in
2016, and consolidation should drive price discipline and margin expansion.
IIKey driver #2: macro tailwinds. Improvements in Europe and Asia (c60%
of Linde Gas), and continued strength in the US, should provide support to a
later-cycle business from 2018 onwards. Industry growth should improve
from 2015-16's 2%.
IIKey driver #3: Praxair merger will create a global leader in the gas
industry.
Our analysis of the combined firm suggests large synergies ($1.2bn — over
20% of pro-forma EBIT — of which $1bn is cost savings and $200m capex
savings).
— The key logic is diversification (geographical and end-user), given
complementary regional and end-market exposures.
IIAnti-trust risks should be manageable, with divestments of $2.5-3bn.
Demand for these assets is likely high.
IIWe forecast €4 3bn net income in 2020, implying a fair value of
€245/share using peer multiples We discount this back, implying our €227
target.
IITrades on 21.6x 2018E P/E, in line with peers.
IICatalysts: greater visibility on merger execution and timing
Related DB Research:
Linde - Gases growth accelerating. Still on track to E245. BUY (Jones)
Pan European Chemicals: 2018 Outlook: A "super" sector (Jones)
Deutsche Bank Research: European Equity Focus — January 2018
Current
Cost
share price synergies
Rerating to
industry
average
Source: Deutsche Bank, Company Data
27
Price
Mid term
discipline target price
Lower
taxes
Relating to
industry
leader
EFTA01432913
Top line
synergies
Blue sky
scenario
15
35
180
15
Linde-Praxair combination a clear market leader
Others
18%
TNS
4%
Air Products
11%
Praxair
13%
Linde
24%
Source: Deutsche Bank estimates, Spiritus Consulting. TNS = Taiyo Nippon
Sanao. Data includes share of sales from associate
participations and .]Vs. Note: Air Liquide includes Airgas acquisition
Linde-Praxair price target bridge
25
245
10
20
300
Air Liquide
30%
EFTA01432914
> Energy, Materials & Industrials
21 Renault — Gaetan Toulemonde. BUY, close €85.2, €115 tgt, 35% upside
IIEmerging markets are the key drivers of the growth, such as: 1) Russia
(delivering €500-700m operating profit growth); 2) Americas (mostly
focused in Brazil and bringing €300-€350m earnings growth); 3) China; 4)
Iran; 5) India.
IIWe expect the profit contribution from Europe to remain stable, at a
high level, in light of modest growth (with Brexit a further drag on the UK)
and regulatory costs.
IIEconomies of scale should drive €700m pa cost savings and thus
increased operating profit. Renault has volumes of only 3.5m units, but in
partnership with Nissan has access to a purchasing department (€120bn)
and an R&D centre (€lObn) of 10m units.
IIAcceleration of synergies with Nissan. It took 18 years (1999-2017) to
have 20% of commonality between the two. It will take 4 years (2018-2021)
to move it to 80%.
IIRenault has an attractive profile in the sector's context, including low
cost
and ultra low cost line up, main sites in low cost countries, EV expertise,
economies of scale and EM exposure
IIRenault's core is far too cheap at the current share price. The current
share price implies a share price of €25/share for Renault's core business.
This is less than 2x P/E for a business still growing EPS at 5% p.a. to
2019E.
IICata
ℹ️ Document Details
SHA-256
d8f88a28a0f105ee62fcb3bb8f583c07a9d69c9ff25c3bbc1b3d50725092cc47
Bates Number
EFTA01432866
Dataset
DataSet-10
Document Type
document
Pages
106
Comments 0