EFTA00792640.pdf

2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association Palm Beach County Bar Association 2017 JUDICIAL EVALUATION SURVEY Voter Information Eligible Voters: 7484 Cast Online Ballot: 636 All Cast Ballots: 636 Particilpation: 8.50% Online Voting: 10/24/17 2:00 PM to 11/16/17 11:00 PM %of Circuit Judges Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers ARTAU, Edward 130 20.4% 4% BARKDULL III, Thomas 168 26.4% 5% j BLANC, Peter 158 24.8% 4% BRUNSON, Catherine 137 21.5% 4% 1. BURTON, Charles 75 11.8% 2% CARACUZZO, Cheryl 135 21.2% 4% COATES, Howard 121 19.0% 3% COLBATH, Jeffrey 81 12.7% 2% FEUER, Samantha Schosberg SO 7.9% 1% FRENCH, David 154 24.2% 4% MI GILLEN, Jeffrey 117 18.4% 3% GOODMAN, Jaimie 175 27.5% 5% 1. HAFELE, Donald 164 25.8% 5% Laura Johnson 75 11.8% 2% John Kastrenakes 84 13.2% 2% Dina Keever 42 6.6% 1% 1. Glenn Kelley 85 13.4% 2% Gregory Keyser 95 14.9% 3% -I. Janis Brustares Keyser 138 21.7% 4% Kathleen Kroll 88 13.8% 2% MI James Martz 53 8.3% 1% Joseph Marx 118 18.6% 3% Krista Marx 78 12.3% 2% Karen Miller 93 14.6% 3% MI Richard Oftedal 125 19.7% 4% Cymonie Rowe 115 18.1% 3% 1.1 Meenu Sasser 188 29.6% 5% Rosemarie Scher 96 15.1% 3% 1. Lisa Small 151 23.7% 4% Scott Suskauer 65 10.2% 2% 1. Jessica Ticktin 130 20.4% 4% Daliah Weiss 41 6.4% 1% J. Kirk Volker 29 4.6% 1% 3554 100% 1 Formatted by BallotBoxOnline LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792640 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association Palm Beach County Bar Association 2017 JUDICIAL EVALUATION SURVEY Voter Information Eligible Voters: 7484 Cast Online Ballot! 636 All Cast Ballots: 636 Particilpation: 8.50% Online Voting: 10/24/17 2:00 PM to 11/16/17 11:00 PM %of County Court Judges Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers August Bonavita 36 5.7% 5% Ted Booras 45 7.1% 6% • Sandra Bosso.Pardo 67 10.5% 9% Marni Bryson 52 8.2% 7% MI Frank Castor 35 5.5% 5% Reginald Corlew 53 8.3% 7% 1. Sheree Cunningham 47 7.4% 6% Paul Damico 52 8.2% 7% a Mark Eissey 37 5.8% 5% Peter Evans 38 6.0% 5% IN Edward Garrison 85 13.4% 11% Leonard Hanser 42 6.6% 6% Robert Panse 40 6.3% 5% Nancy Perez 58 9.1% 8% 1. Caroline Shepherd 29 4.6% 4% Debra Moses Stephens 47 7.4% 6% 763 100% %of Magistrates Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers Sara Alijewicz 39 6.1% 14% Thomas Baker 44 6.9% 16% Peter Bassaline 31 4.9% 11% Judette Fanelli 24 3.8% 9% Linda Goodwin 19 3.0% 7% Diane Kirigin 44 6.9% 16% MI Jean-Adel Williams 17 2.7% 6% Maxine Williams 35 5.5% 13% 1.1 Sarah Willis 27 4.2% 10% 280 100% %of Judges of Compensation Claims Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers Thomas A. Hedler 5 0.8% 42% Gregory J. Johnsen 7 1.1% 58% 12 100% 2 Formatted by BallotBoxOnline LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792641 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association ARTAU, Edward % of Certification Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers I hereby certify that I have had at least one (1) trial or three (3) hearings before this Judge within the last two (2) years 130 100.0% 100% Knowledge & Application of Law Excellent 49 37.7% 38% Satisfactory 51 39.2% 39% Needs Improvement 26 20.0% 20% Not answered 4 3.1% 3% 130 100.0% 100% Impartiality Excellent 72 55.4% SS% Satisfactory 49 37.7% 38% Needs Improvement 8 6.2% 6% Not answered 1 0.8% 1% 130 100.0% 100% Diligence & Preparedness Excellent 54 41.5% 42% Satisfactory 46 35.4% 35% Needs Improvement 26 20.0% 20% Not answered 4 3.1% 3% 130 100.0% 100% Judicial Demeanor Excellent 65 50.0% 50% Satisfactory 48 36.9% 37% Needs Improvement 15 11.5% 12% Not answered 2 1.5% 2% 130 100.0% 100% Control of Courtroom Excellent 47 36.2% 36% Satisfactory 50 38.5% 38% Needs Improvement 30 23.1% 23% Not answered 3 2.3% 2% 130 100.0% 100% Case Management Excellent 39 30.0% 30% Satisfactory 52 40.0% 40% Needs Improvement 26 20.0% 20% Not answered 13 10.0% 10% 130 100.0% 100% Punctuality & Timeliness Excellent 47 36.2% 36% Satisfactory 40 30.8% 31% Needs Improvement 38 29.2% 29% Not answered 5 3.8% 4% 130 100.0% 100% Common Sense Excellent 55 42.3% 42% Satisfactory 50 38.5% 38% Needs Improvement 22 16.9% 17% Nor answered 3 2.3% 2% 130 100.0% 100% Enforcement of Standards of Professionalism Excellent 70 53.8% 54% Satisfactory 46 35.4% 35% Needs Improvement 9 6.9% 7% Not answered 5 3.8% 4% 130 100.0% 100% 3 Formatted by SallothozOnlme LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792642 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association BARKDULL III, Thomas %of Certification Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers I hereby certify that I have had at least one (1) trial or three (3) hearings before this judge within the last two (2) years 168 100.0% 100% Knowledge & Application of Law Excellent 85 50.6% 51% Satisfactory 52 31.0% 31% Needs Improvement 31 18.5% 18% 168 100.0% 100% Impartiality Excellent 50 29.8% 30% Satisfactory 42 25.0% 25% Needs Improvement 74 44.0% 44% Not onswered 2 1.2% 1% 168 100.0% 100% Diligence & Preparedness Excellent 82 48.8% 49% Satisfactory 64 38.1% 38% Needs Improvement 20 11.9% 12% Not onswered 2 1.2% 1% 168 100.0% 100% Judicial Demeanor Excellent 36 21.4% 21% Satisfactory 43 25.6% 26% Needs Improvement 87 51.8% 52% Not onswered 2 1.2% 1% 168 100.0% 100% Control of Courtroom Excellent 93 55.4% 55% Satisfactory 52 31.0% 31% Needs Improvement 20 11.9% 12% Not onswered 3 1.8% 2% 168 100.0% 100% Case Management Excellent 79 47.0% 47% Satisfactory 64 38.1% 38% Needs Improvement 18 10.7% 11% Not onswered 7 4.2% 4% 168 100.0% 100% Punctuality & Timeliness Excellent 106 63.1% 63% Satisfactory 52 31.0% 31% Needs Improvement 9 5.4% 5% Not onswered 1 0.6% 1% 168 100.0% 100% Common Sense Excellent 74 44.0% 44% Satisfactory 45 26.8% 27% Needs Improvement 49 29.2% 29% 168 100.0% 100% Enforcement of Standards of Professionalism Excellent 77 45.8% 46% Satisfactory 49 29.2% 29% Needs Improvement 35 20.8% 21% Not onswered 7 4.2% 4% 168 100.0% 100% 4 Formatted by BallotBoxOnline LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792643 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association BLANC, Peter %of Certification Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers I hereby certify that I have had at least one (1) trial or three (3) hearings before this judge within the last two (2) years 158 100.0% 100% Knowledge & Application of Law Excellent 128 81.0% 81% Satisfactory 19 12.0% 12% Needs Improvement 7 4.4% 4% Not onswered 4 2.5% 3% 158 100.0% 100% Impartiality Excellent 120 75.9% 76% Satisfactory 21 13.3% 13% Needs Improvement 14 8.9% 9% Not onswered 3 1.9% 2% 158 100.0% 100% Diligence & Preparedness Excellent 127 80.4% 80% Satisfactory 21 13.3% 13% Needs Improvement 6 3.8% 4% Not onswered 4 2.5% 3% 158 100.0% 100% Judicial Demeanor Excellent 110 69.6% 70% Satisfactory 36 22.8% 23% Needs Improvement 10 6.3% 6% Not onswered 2 1.3% 1% 158 100.0% 100% Control of Courtroom Excellent 130 82.3% 82% Satisfactory 21 13.3% 13% Needs Improvement 5 3.2% 3% Not onswered 2 1.3% 1% 158 100.0% 100% Case Management Excellent 119 75.3% 75% Satisfactory 27 17.1% 17% Needs Improvement 6 3.8% 4% Not onswered 6 3.8% 4% 158 100.0% 100% Punctuality & Timeliness Excellent 125 79.1% 79% Satisfactory 26 16.5% 16% Needs Improvement 4 2.5% 3% Not onswered 3 1.9% 2% 158 100.0% 100% Common Sense Excellent 124 78.5% 78% Satisfactory 21 13.3% 13% Needs Improvement 10 6.3% 6% Not answered 3 1.9% 2% 158 100.0% 100% Enforcement of Standards of Professionalism Excellent 123 77.8% 78% Satisfactory 16 10.1% 10% Needs Improvement 7 4.4% 4% Not onswered 12 7.6% 8% 158 100.0% 100% Formatted by BallotBoxOnline LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792644 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association BRUNSON, Catherine %of Certification Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers I hereby certify that I have had at least one (1) trial or three (3) hearings before this judge within the last two (2) years 137 100.0% 100% Knowledge & Application of Law Excellent 29 21.2% 21% Satisfactory 69 50.4% 50% Needs Improvement 39 28.5% 28% 137 100.0% 100% Impartiality Excellent 79 57.7% 58% Satisfactory 51 37.2% 37% Needs Improvement 6 4.4% 4% Not onswered 1 0.7% 1% 137 100.0% 100% Diligence & Preparedness Excellent 35 25.5% 26% Satisfactory 76 55.5% 55% Needs Improvement 25 18.2% 18% Not onswered 1 0.7% 1% 137 100.0% 100% Judicial Demeanor Excellent 90 65.7% 66% Satisfactory 38 27.7% 28% Needs Improvement 8 5.8% 6% Not onswered 1 0.7% 1% 137 100.0% 100% Control of Courtroom Excellent 46 33.6% 34% Satisfactory 64 46.7% 47% Needs Improvement 24 17.5% 18% Not onswered 3 2.2% 2% 137 100.0% 100% Case Management Excellent 32 23.4% 23% Satisfactory 66 48.2% 48% Needs Improvement 37 27.0% 27% Not onswered 2 1.5% 1% 137 100.0% 100% Punctuality & Timeliness Excellent 55 40.1% 40% Satisfactory 64 46.7% 47% Needs Improvement 14 10.2% 10% Not onswered 4 2.9% 3% 137 100.0% 100% Common Sense Excellent 45 32.8% 33% Satisfactory 60 43.2% 44% Needs Improvement 30 21.9% 22% Not answered 2 1.5% 1% 137 100.0% 100% Enforcement of Standards of Professionalism Excellent 54 39.4% 39% Satisfactory 60 43.8% 44% Needs Improvement 9 6.6% 7% Not onswered 14 10.2% 10% 137 100.0% 100% 6 Formatted by BallotBoxOnline LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792645 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association BURTON, Charles %of Certification Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers I hereby certify that I have had at least one (1) trial or three (3) hearings before this judge within the last two (2) years 75 100.0% 100% Knowledge & Application of Law Excellent 47 62.7% 63% Satisfactory 25 33.3% 33% Needs Improvement 1 1.3% 1% Not onswered 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Impartiality Excellent 56 74.7% 75% Satisfactory 16 21.3% 21% Needs Improvement 2 2.7% 3% Not onswered 1 1.3% 1% 75 100.0% 100% Diligence & Preparedness Excellent 43 57.3% 57% Satisfactory 28 37.3% 37% Needs Improvement 2 2.7% 3% Not onswered 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Judicial Demeanor Excellent 58 77.3% 77% Satisfactory 15 20.0% 20% Needs Improvement 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Control of Courtroom Excellent 55 73.3% 73% Satisfactory 18 24.0% 24% Needs Improvement 0 0.0% 0% Not onswered 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Case Management Excellent 50 66.7% 67% Satisfactory 23 30.7% 31% Needs Improvement 0 0.0% 0% Not onswered 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Punctuality & Timeliness Excellent 54 72.0% 72% Satisfactory 18 24.0% 24% Needs Improvement 1 1.3% 1% Not onswered 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Common Sense Excellent 63 84.0% 84% Satisfactory 8 10.7% 11% Needs Improvement 2 2.7% 3% Not onswered 2 2.7% 3% 75 100.0% 100% Enforcement of Standards of Professionalism Excellent 55 73.3% 73% Satisfactory 14 18.7% 19% Needs Improvement 3 4.0% 4% Not onswered 3 4.0% 4% 75 100.0% 100% 7 Formatted by BallotBoxOnline LLC www.BallotBoxOnline.com EFTA00792646 2017 Judicial Evaluation Survey Online Voting: 10/24/17 to 11/16/17 Palm Beach County Bar Association CARACUZZO, Cheryl % of Certification Number of Votes Respondents % of Answers I hereby certify that I have had at least one (1) trial or three (3) hearings before this Judge within the last two (2) years 135 100.0% 100% Knowledge & Application of Law Excellent 71 52.6% 53% Satisfactory 48 35.6% 36% Needs Improvement 13 9.6% 10% Not answered 3 2.2% 2%