gov.uscourts.nysd.447706.156.7.pdf PDF
…are not relevant to any party’s claim or defense, are not proportional to the needs of the case, and creates …
…are not relevant to any party’s claim or defense, are not proportional to the needs of the case, and creates …
…decision by the Court to undercut that purpose. Should Does 1 and 2 wish to submit a more thorough explanation for their objection, doing so would be to the benefit of all involved in this process. Third, and relatedly, that …
…whether the party requesting the deposition has had other opportunities to obtain the same information, and whether the burden of a second deposition outweighs its potential benefit.’” Id. (quoting Ganci, 1 Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1330…
…Therefore, the Court can have the benefit of whichever format it prefers to work from. Plaintiff’s format includes the specifics of sealed orders and details of the sealed exhibits for ease of the Court’s reference and accordingly is…
…455 at 2. In the interests of judicial economy, the parties believe it would be appropriate to have the benefit of the Court's rulings on these other issues, review the designated testimony in light of such rulings and then…
…not proportional to the needs of the case. Such requests would create a heavy burden on Ms. Giuffre that outweighs any benefit. Such discovery is prohibited by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, particularly under the 2015 amendments to Rule…
…it references J. Doe 1 or 2, so that the Court has the benefit of the “Related Docket #” column listing the related filings. Ms. Maxwell submits that consideration of the motions in chronological order is the most logical, efficient and…
…in resolvingthe issu es,and whetherthe bu rd en orex pense of the proposed d iscovery ou tweighs its likely benefit. Ru le 26(b)(1),Fed .R.C iv.P .D efend ant’s d iscovery requ ests foremploymentand…
…fundamentally unfair to allow Giuffre to continue to press these allegations where she and her attorneys have had the full benefit of discovery already conducted concerning these allegations which is in her possession and which is being withheld Dershowitz and…
…for two hour on each subject, up to a total of four hours. The Defendant should not get a benefit from having twice improperly withheld information, by collapsing the two hours needed to address each of these topics into an…
…of 12 has shut. Expert reports have been exchanged, so Ms. Giuffre’s experts did not have the benefit of reviewing these documents. Late production of this information robs Ms. Giuffre of any practical ability to use the discovery, and…
…that that counsel feels must be redacted, can 13 it be just redacted? 14 THE COURT: Of course. 15 MS. WALZ: So we can have the benefit of the chart. 16 THE COURT: Of course. Yes, indeed. 17 And, counsel…
…sanctions, “to ‘ensure that a party will not benefit from its own failure to comply,’ to ‘obtain compliance with a particular order issued,’ and to ‘serve a general deterrent 4 Plaintiff lodged an objection to communications regarding “ongoing” investigations, but…
…– i.e. the alleged benefit she was promised. The few documents produced suggest that the denial of admission to F.I.T. (if that is what occurred) is more likely a result of lack of required credentials or her failure…
…19 10. “Income” includes, without limitation, any revenue, payments, compensation, remuneration, financial benefit or support or any other financial consideration, or provision of any other thing of value. 11. “Person” means any natural person, individual, firm, partnership, association, joint venture…
…deprive the adversary of vital information."). 16 Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1327-9 Filed 01/05/24 Page 18 of 21 expense of additional depositions would outweigh any likely benefit." In re Weatherford Int'l Sec…
…are not relevant to any party’s claim or defense, are not proportional to the needs of the case, and creates …
…foreign or domestic, directly or indirectly held by You, or held on Your behalf or for Your benefit by another individual or entity, including trusts from January 2015 to the Present. DOCUMENT REQUEST NO. 34 Produce all accounts receivable ledgers…
…other than the one selected by the party seeking discovery.” Even among parties, the Court has discretion to impose discovery limitations where the “burden or expense of the proposed discovery outweighs its likely benefit, considering the needs of the case…
…untimely and prejudicial. Fact discovery has closed. Numerous depositions have already been taken by Ms. Giuffre without the benefit of these documents. The window for authenticating the documents through depositions 7 has shut. Expert reports have been exchanged, so Ms…
Comments