…to answer questions on this subject. And, once again, Ms. Giuffre was forced to move to compel answers. And, once again, the Court ordered Defendant to answer questions about the subjects she had refused to address, enumerating four specific topics…
…she had no memory of any of the events. As a result, Ms. Giuffre was forced to file a Motion to Compel Defendant to Answer Deposition Questions Filed under Seal (DE 143). On June 20, 2016, this Court granted Ms…
…the exhibits to Professor Dershowitz’s Reply Declaration are confidential—and the declaration makes only a few brief references to materials that may be deemed confidential—Professor Dershowitz was nonetheless forced to redact large swaths of the publicly filed version…
…disregard of the Court’s compelling reasons for permitting the parties to seal materials. This case involved plaintiff’s claim she had been “forced” to be a “child” “sex slave” for a long list of prominent men. She accused Ms…
…Allowing the Defendant in this case to force this non-party to provide discovery on this highly sensitive topic would be both oppressive and unreasonable and serves no purpose other than to foster Defendant’s publicly admitted and utterly baseless…
…Maxwell “in her deposition [on April 25] raised Ms. Giuffre’s comments about President Clinton as one of the ‘obvious lies’ to which she was referring in her public statement that formed the basis of this suit.” Reply at 3…
…Paragraph 13 provides that the Protective Order “shall have no force and effect on the use of any [confidential information] at trial[.]” The parties thus clearly contemplated that the Protective Order may be modified in the future and would not…
…Ms. Maxwell’s denial of those statements substantially true.7 Plaintiff has been forced to admit that her repeated claims and sworn statements that she became a “sex slave” in 1999 when she was 15 years old are untrue. She…
…called them “sleazy, unprofessional and unethical.” The controversy started in December 2014, when Roberts claimed that convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein forced her to have sex with Dershowitz, the U.K’.s Prince Andrew and other men, at Epstein’s…
…Dershowitz’s request to modify the Maxwell Protective Order, it will not in the same breath force him to litigate this action with one arm tied behind his back. 5 At a hearing before the Court on December 2, 2019…
…this assertion, implying knowledge of the contents of the Sealed Materials, that alone is a violation of the Protection Order. As Plaintiff well knows, Ms. Maxwell was forced to answer substantial, numerous, ill- founded questions regarding her private life, her…
…find her. Jane Doe 43 Dep. Tr. 177; 257. x She was forced by Epstein to have sex with other girls and with a colleague of Epstein’s in his New York mansion. Jane Doe 43 Dep. Tr. 187-192…
…argue that they should be fellow travelers in this pursuit, lest they “be forced to file a separate suit raising their claims” resulting in “duplicative litigation” (DE 280 at 11). The Court finds that justice does not require adding new…
… Ms. Maxwell was forced to show the Court all the questions she had answered beyond those authorized by the Court’s order and the number of repetitive and harassing questions. This submission of the July 2016 transcript to the Court…
…Ms. Maxwell played some role in Mr. Epstein’s counsel’s refusal to accept service. See Mot. at 2 (“forced to personally serve the Defendant’s former boyfriend, employer, and co-conspirator”). As the timeline and documents now reveal, however…
…52-60 (Defendant’s friend’s house manager, through tears, described how Defendant tried to force a 15 year old Swedish girl to have sex with Epstein through threats and stealing her passport); Juan Alessi’s June 1, 2016 Dep…
…43 Filed 07/15/21 Page 6 of 12 hasn’t been completed correctly.”) Ms. Giuffre had to then litigate, extensively, to force Defendant to perform a proper collection and search, and, correctly, in response to the Motion to Compel…
…argue that they should be fellow travelers in this pursuit, lest they “be forced to file a separate suit raising their claims” resulting in “duplicative litigation” (DE 280 at 11). The Court finds that justice does not require adding new…
…Subpoena (pending). Similarly, the Court will recall that Ms. Giuffre was recently forced to resort to the Hague Convention in an effort to depose Maxwell’s spokesman, Ross Gow, about statements he made on Defendant’s behalf. See DE 306…
…10 Accordingly, the Court will be forced to sort through such issues if it allows these deposition excerpts to be used at trial. It is far simpler for everyone if the Court simply requires Defendant to ask questions of Ms…