📄 Extracted Text (822 words)
DARREN K. INDYKE
Darren K. Indyke, PLLC
575 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor
New York, New York 10022
Telephone:
Telecopier.
Email:
June 25, 2018
VIA Email --
Mr. Brian Walden
Director of Operations
ProSolar America, LLC
Dear Mr. Walden:
I am general counsel to Great St. Jim, LLC and LSJE, LLC ("GSJ"), which own and operate
Great St. James Island in the U.S. Virgin Islands.
I understand that GSJ purchased a 310.8 kWh solar power system from ProSolar Systems,
LLC ("ProSolar") in November 2016 for a purchase price of $192,211. Included as part of that
purchase were 12 self-contained Acquion Maintenance Free Salt Water Battery Modules for an
aggregate price of $154,338, each being sold with a 3-year warranty from ProSolar, which will
not expire before November 2019. I also understand that GSJ has also been paying ProSolar in
the amount of $350 per month for monthly maintenance/service calls which have been taking
place since April 2017 and that after Hurricanes Irma and Maria hit the U.S Virgin Islands in
September 2017, GSJ paid in excess of $111,000 to troubleshoot and bring the solar power
system into full operation.
Despite the purchase of a specially designed solar power system that was to provide Great
St. James Island with continuous power to meet its energy demands (which GSJ fully disclosed in
advance to ProSolar) without interruption on a full-time basis, and was warranted for three years,
the power system now fails regularly, shutting down like clockwork every morning at
approximately SAM. This then requires GSJ's representative to travel to the island to turn off
island-wide power drawing from the system, so that the system can recharge. Once the system
recharges, it then must reboot completely before GSJ's representative can reconnect power to
Great St. James. Obviously, this was not what was proposed by ProSolar, not what was agreed
to and certainly not what GSJ paid almost $200,000 for ProSolar to deliver. Moreover, after more
than year of paid monthly service calls and an additional $111,000 of replacement and repair
work to bring the solar power system into full operation over the past several months, and
despite ProSolar's knowledge of the existing conditions on Great St. James Island and continued
EFTA00799453
Mr. Brian Walden
Director of Operations
June 25, 2018
Page 2 of 2
reports to ProSolar of increasingly regular low voltage system failures, only recently did ProSolar
tech personnel open the battery modules to examine the circuit boards contained therein that
supply the charging and discharging controls for each battery module to discover that several
were corroded. This is what ProSolar has advised it now believes is the source of the problem.
ProSolar has proposed a solution to modify the solar power system it designed for,
supplied to, and installed on Great St. James and has been servicing. It proposes to bypass the
circuit boards contained in each of the 12 battery modules in the system and allow the control
functions that were to be performed by those circuit boards now to be performed by the existing
inverters of the system which were also supplied, installed and serviced by ProSolar. ProSolar
proposes to reprogram those inverters to assume the functionality of the bypassed circuit
boards. It believes that the transfer of the control functions from the circuit boards to the
inverters will eliminate the low voltage system failures Great St. James has been experiencing
and will allow the system to function as contractually required and warranted.
We appreciate your efforts to diagnose the catastrophic failures with the solar power
system you designed, supplied, assembled and have been servicing. And we are more than
willing to allow you at your sole cost and expense to attempt to fix the problem along the lines
that you propose. However, please be advised that should your proposed solution fail, we insist
that you honor your obligation to deliver to Great St. James Island a solar power system with the
full functionality you contracted to deliver and warranted by replacing the system with one that
actually performs as agreed, or provide GSJ with a full refund of all amounts paid to ProSolar in
connection with the system, including, without limitation, the $192,211 paid for the system, the
$111,000 paid to bring the system into operation and the $350 per month of ProSolar's service
calls that never properly diagnosed or fixed the system's problems.
Please advise when you will begin the necessary work to implement your proposed
solution, so that appropriate arrangements can be made on Great St. James Island.
This letter is without prejudice to the rights and claims of GSJ against ProSolar, including,
without limitation, the right to bring legal action against ProSolar to recover all amounts incurred
by GSJ in connection with the solar power system delivered by ProSolar, consequential damages
and attorneys fees and costs, all of which rights and claims are hereby expressly reserved.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Darren K. Indyke
Darren K. Indyke
EFTA00799454
ℹ️ Document Details
SHA-256
beb6b99abd2c639cae8461c59a642a1e609c123513a33a38c2a06fd1ec90c678
Bates Number
EFTA00799453
Dataset
DataSet-9
Document Type
document
Pages
2
Comments 0