…her lack of credibility, her failures of memory and her selective use of law enforcement. Regarding the year 2015, the police reports demonstrate Plaintiff’s tumultuous home life, bearing no relationship to any press statements or alleged defamation and providing…
…wants to publicize police reports concerning Ms. Giuffre - most of them from when she was a child, some of them concerning her being raped when only 14 years. Defendant’s challenge to Ms. Giuffre’s confidentiality designation is without merit…
…Unsealing Decided Motions, sixteen non-parties submitted Non-Party Objections in November and December of last year.1 Addressing these Non- Party Objections now will allow the Court to adjudicate all remaining legal arguments against unsealing at once, and will…
…wants to publicize police reports concerning Ms. Giuffre - most of them from when she was a child, some of them concerning her being raped when only 14 years. Defendant’s challenge to Ms. Giuffre’s confidentiality designation is without merit…
…a requirement, however, and in the intervening years courts in this District have presided over numerous Epstein-related cases and handled sealing (and unsealing) motions without soliciting objections from third parties who were mentioned in the documents. See, e.g…
…a particular set of documents. That is inconsistent with Paragraph 2(j). And it could take years before the Court could unseal even the First Five Motions. Docket Entry 143 and its accompanying briefing, for example, contains approximately 15 Non…
…access to those documents, to which they have a First Amendment right of access, for years. And if Maxwell’s meritless objections prevail, the public will never have access to those documents. Recognizing Plaintiff’s concern, the Court stated in…
…6 THE COURT: Here is the deal. We are not doing all 7 the documents at the same time because that would take you 12 8 years to brief and me 12 years to decide. 9 MS. McCAWLEY: Right. 10 …
…enforceable, witnesses relying upon such orders will be inhibited from giving essential testimony in civil litigation, thus undermining a procedural system that has been successfully developed over the years for disposition of civil disputes. 594 F.2d at 295–96…
…rejected these broad subpoenas. 15 Defendants know that they are not entitled to every 16 single personal email plaintiff has ever sent or ever received 17 in the course of however many years these accounts were open. 18 In fact…
…fully understand the extent of the allegations – the same allegations that law enforcement and prosecutors may have been aware of years ago when offering a plea deal to Mr. Epstein – the accuser’s stories should be disclosed to the public…
…for briefing motions to suppress that begins in January 2021. Disclosure of witnesses, Rule 404(b) and 415 evidence, Jencks and Giglio material is unlikely to occur until later next year. Yet, to release this potentially inadmissible evidence publicly now…
…some of the many squabbles and disputes -- and 20 I emphasize the word "many" -- that the parties had in 21 connection with the discovery in this case. 22 The Court may recall that about two years ago, 23 March 17…
…31, 2020). These parties’ identities were pseudonymized by referring to them on the public record as “Does,” i.e., “Doe 1,” “Doe 2,” and so on. Over the next few years, the district court individually reviewed hundreds of sealed documents…
…allegations in the Sealed Materials may be the product of false statements, mistake, confusion, or failing memories based upon events occurring more than sixteen years ago. And, critically, such allegations will never be resolved here in light of the parties…
…ence.The C omplaintat paragraph9 pu rports to d escribe events pertainingto P laintiff and D efend antoccu rringin the years 1999 –20 0 2.The C omplaintalso references statements attribu ted to M s.M ax well occu rringin…
…does not apply to statements made in court filings (like those at issue here), which should have been unsealed and made public years ago. J. Does 1 and 2 have not asserted any objections with regard to these materials, …
…her lack of credibility, her failures of memory and her selective use of law enforcement. Regarding the year 2015, the police reports demonstrate Plaintiff’s tumultuous home life, bearing no relationship to any press statements or alleged defamation and providing…
…172, and 1992 results in a determination that: (a) the selected Sealed Materials relate solely to five-year-old discovery disputes and therefore, at most, begin with a presumption of public access “somewhat lower than the presumption applied to material…
…process. At the same time we think it appropriate to point out that the Court and the parties are effectively doing a substantial amount of work that took place over a two-year period and encompassed hundreds of court submissions…
Comments